Skip to main content
. 2013 Jun 13;8(6):e65471. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0065471

Table 5. Effect of the intervention on adherence to the guideline for the clinical behaviours x-ray referral, imaging referral, advice regarding activity and bed rest, as measured by response to the vignettes (behavioural simulation outcomes).

Variable Intervention group adherence1 Control group adherence2 Adjusted Odds Ratio3 (95% CI) p-value
No. (%) No. (%)
X-ray adherence4 126/152 (83) 109/160 (68) 1.76* (1.01, 3.05) 0.045
Imaging adherence4 119/152 (78) 89/160 (56) 2.36* (1.48, 3.79) 0.000
Activity adherence5 121/152 (80) 82/160 (51) 4.49 (1.90, 10.60) 0.001
Bed rest adherence6 163/164 (99) 168/171 (98) 2.91* (0.30, 27.83) 0.354
1

No. Practices = 31 and No. GPs = 38, except for variable “Bed rest adherence” where No. Practices = 34 and No. GPs = 41.

2

No. Practices = 36 and No. GPs = 40, except for variable “Bed rest adherence” where No. Practices = 38 and No. GPs = 43.

3

Adjusted odds ratios estimated from logistic models fitted using GEEs with an exchangeable correlation structure and robust variance estimation to allow for clustering within general practices. For models where the estimated within cluster correlation was negative (indicated by *), the model was refitted assuming an independent correlation structure.

4

Model adjusted for the design strata (number of GPs per practice, location of practice [metropolitan or rural/remote]) and confounders specified prior to undertaking the analysis (age of GP (years), years since GP graduated, special interest in LBP, practice method of billing [bulk bill or co-payment]).

5

Model adjusted for the same design strata and confounders as in footnote 4, with the addition of the baseline measure of GP fear-avoidance beliefs.

6

The planned model was to have included adjustment for the same design strata and confounders as in footnote 5, however; due to limited events of non-adherence the model was fitted with no adjustment for the design strata and confounders.