Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Jan 1.
Published in final edited form as: Commun Stat Simul Comput. 2012 Dec 12;42(6):1213–1234. doi: 10.1080/03610918.2012.661906

Table 2.

Point estimate simulation on J*. Bias and RMSE on the optimal Youden index (J*) estimation from five methods (N, TN, EMP, KS, KS-SJ) based on 1000 simulated datasets.

Scenario # obs 20 50 100 200

J 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8
Normal Bias
N 0.00547 0.00409 0.00265 0.00068 0.00256 0.00151 0.00047 −0.00037 0.00070 0.00033 −0.00006 −0.00046 −0.00016 −0.00025 −0.00031 −0.00024
TN 0.00478 0.00389 0.00214 −0.00122 0.00267 0.00226 0.00112 −0.00066 0.00144 0.00137 0.00093 0.00005 0.00039 0.00041 0.00034 0.00018
EMP 0.02178 0.02038 0.02213 0.02038 0.00928 0.00887 0.00814 0.00683 0.00481 0.00408 0.00386 0.00350 0.00244 0.00223 0.00222 0.00210
KS −0.02854 −0.03879 −0.04268 −0.03111 −0.02955 −0.03710 −0.03981 −0.02935 −0.02648 −0.03218 −0.03363 −0.02441 −0.02242 −0.02656 −0.02746 −0.01988
KS-SJ −0.02399 −0.03419 −0.03814 −0.02766 −0.02769 −0.03526 −0.03812 −0.02823 −0.02547 −0.03133 −0.03287 −0.02388 −0.02184 −0.02603 −0.02701 −0.01960
RMSE
N 0.06392 0.06294 0.05868 0.05048 0.04190 0.04104 0.03812 0.03253 0.02970 0.02909 0.02693 0.02292 0.02068 0.02015 0.01856 0.01580
TN 0.06485 0.06386 0.05979 0.05209 0.04236 0.04151 0.03857 0.03322 0.03035 0.02967 0.02742 0.02329 0.02093 0.02036 0.01871 0.01592
EMP 0.08457 0.08133 0.07500 0.06210 0.05593 0.05362 0.04961 0.04062 0.04028 0.03812 0.03485 0.02901 0.02837 0.02681 0.02420 0.02041
KS 0.07250 0.07749 0.07664 0.06225 0.05359 0.05806 0.05803 0.04578 0.04207 0.04553 0.04501 0.03482 0.03227 0.03489 0.03451 0.02657
KS-SJ 0.07225 0.07652 0.07522 0.06141 0.05305 0.05731 0.05729 0.04526 0.04215 0.04557 0.04498 0.03481 0.03236 0.03496 0.03455 0.02662

Log-
Normal
Bias
N 0.09082 0.06199 0.01187 −0.05147 0.09178 0.05494 −0.00088 −0.06736 0.09076 0.05128 −0.00628 −0.07370 0.08937 0.04821 −0.01039 −0.07831
TN 0.00370 0.00422 0.00378 0.00141 0.00247 0.00221 0.00148 0.00015 0.00049 0.00054 0.00034 −0.00022 −0.00028 −0.00023 −0.00017 −0.00017
EMP 0.01990 0.01858 0.01768 0.01865 0.00797 0.00481 0.00525 0.00599 0.00349 0.00175 0.00146 0.00344 0.00073 0.00048 0.00009 0.00111
KS 0.00843 −0.00222 −0.02557 −0.05953 0.00454 −0.00442 −0.02710 −0.05881 0.00229 −0.00414 −0.02389 −0.05280 0.00119 −0.00292 −0.01979 −0.04616
KS-SJ 0.00717 0.00122 −0.01440 −0.04123 0.00290 −0.00038 −0.01305 −0.03585 0.00019 −0.00104 −0.00999 −0.02866 −0.00091 −0.00092 −0.00696 −0.02194
RMSE
N 0.11239 0.08060 0.04833 0.07049 0.10085 0.06394 0.03171 0.07553 0.09552 0.05676 0.02553 0.07852 0.09181 0.05140 0.02147 0.08105
TN 0.06586 0.06470 0.05984 0.05052 0.04304 0.04216 0.03890 0.03262 0.03056 0.02992 0.02757 0.02301 0.02125 0.02072 0.01894 0.01577
EMP 0.08223 0.08307 0.07532 0.06393 0.05364 0.05278 0.04918 0.04080 0.03887 0.03821 0.03525 0.02866 0.02782 0.02692 0.02442 0.02011
KS 0.06822 0.06060 0.05950 0.07806 0.04555 0.04020 0.04461 0.06740 0.03376 0.03006 0.03540 0.05782 0.02387 0.02145 0.02713 0.04911
KS-SJ 0.06941 0.06373 0.05717 0.06496 0.04587 0.04248 0.03889 0.04827 0.03404 0.03161 0.02908 0.03697 0.02439 0.02272 0.02075 0.02751

Gamma Bias
N 0.06135 0.06186 0.04176 0.00064 0.05785 0.05770 0.03654 −0.00459 0.05577 0.05565 0.03447 −0.00630 0.05507 0.05488 0.03356 −0.00720
TN 0.00833 0.00577 0.00357 0.00110 0.00729 0.00718 0.00623 0.00308 0.00553 0.00586 0.00540 0.00301 0.00451 0.00500 0.00471 0.00256
EMP 0.03405 0.02305 0.02128 0.01893 0.01534 0.01033 0.01019 0.00956 0.01028 0.00822 0.00761 0.00520 0.00361 0.00204 0.00205 0.00279
KS 0.00025 −0.00667 −0.01712 −0.03429 −0.00562 −0.01109 −0.01994 −0.03442 −0.00626 −0.01049 −0.01798 −0.03060 −0.00590 −0.00895 −0.01498 −0.02601
KS-SJ 0.00503 −0.00102 −0.00879 −0.02390 −0.00047 −0.00467 −0.01025 −0.02204 −0.00091 −0.00383 −0.00830 −0.01782 −0.00121 −0.00309 −0.00635 −0.01382
RMSE
N 0.08931 0.08240 0.06197 0.04202 0.07131 0.06708 0.04675 0.02770 0.06336 0.06086 0.04039 0.02067 0.05873 0.05735 0.03647 0.01523
TN 0.06364 0.06490 0.06149 0.05161 0.04025 0.04068 0.03849 0.03260 0.02848 0.02873 0.02719 0.02318 0.01974 0.01987 0.01869 0.01570
EMP 0.07826 0.07619 0.07332 0.06164 0.05146 0.05022 0.04830 0.03943 0.03750 0.03596 0.03430 0.02913 0.02614 0.02523 0.02327 0.01989
KS 0.06019 0.05855 0.05613 0.05884 0.04041 0.04031 0.04115 0.04689 0.02993 0.03036 0.03197 0.03860 0.02201 0.02191 0.02362 0.03057
KS-SJ 0.06092 0.05880 0.05454 0.05361 0.04077 0.03975 0.03772 0.03848 0.02962 0.02910 0.02800 0.02946 0.02194 0.02089 0.01983 0.02135