Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Mar 13.
Published in final edited form as: J Chem Theory Comput. 2013 Jan 9;9(3):1417–1427. doi: 10.1021/ct3010134

Table 4.

Summary of mDC and DFTB2 cluster binding energy (ΔE) and cluster relative energies (ΔΔE) errors (kcal mol−1) relative to the MP2, MP2+CP, and 〈MP2〉 reference values. The coordinate root mean square statistics (a.u.) are relative to the structure before geometry optimization, which are the DFTB2 isolated waters superimposed onto the optimized MP2 cluster geometry.

Ref. Cluster ΔE
ΔΔE
rms
mDC DFTB2 mDC DFTB2 mDC DFTB2
MP2 (H2O)4 mse 3.38 11.57 −1.65 −2.90 ··· ···
mue 3.38 11.57 1.69 2.90 0.28 0.66
max 4.78 13.89 −4.08 −5.15 0.48 2.03
(H2O)5 mse 5.73 16.86 −0.78 −2.38 ··· ···
mue 5.73 16.86 0.80 2.38 0.37 0.61
max 6.47 18.90 −2.69 −4.73 1.08 1.23
(H2O)6 mse 7.57 21.88 −0.08 −0.74 ··· ···
mue 7.57 21.88 0.36 1.15 0.40 0.73
max 8.26 23.78 −0.81 −7.24 1.35 2.88
MP2+CP (H2O)4 mse −2.91 5.28 −0.49 −1.74 ··· ···
mue 2.91 5.28 0.69 1.74 ··· ···
max −4.87 6.67 −2.35 −3.42 ··· ···
(H2O)5 mse −3.34 7.79 0.11 −1.49 ··· ···
mue 3.34 7.79 0.54 1.49 ··· ···
max −4.72 9.07 −1.28 −3.32 ··· ···
(H2O)6 mse −4.09 10.22 0.55 −0.11 ··· ···
mue 4.09 10.22 0.55 0.92 ··· ···
max −4.61 11.78 1.65 −4.86 ··· ···
〈MP2〉 (H2O)4 mse 0.23 8.42 −1.07 −2.32 ··· ···
mue 1.09 8.42 1.13 2.32 ··· ···
max −2.13 10.28 −3.22 −4.28 ··· ···
(H2O)5 mse 1.19 12.33 −0.33 −1.93 ··· ···
mue 1.34 12.33 0.52 1.93 ··· ···
max 1.90 13.99 −1.98 −4.02 ··· ···
(H2O)6 mse 1.74 16.05 0.24 −0.43 ··· ···
mue 1.74 16.05 0.33 1.01 ··· ···
max 2.54 17.78 1.02 −6.05 ··· ···