Table 2.
Results of the systematic review: the effect of agricultural price policies on nutritional status and health
Author (year) | Country | Policy | Commodities | Data sources | Methods | Outcome | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Panel A: undernutrition outcome | |||||||
Tarozzi11 | India (Andhra Pradesh) | Indian food subsidy programme | Rice, wheat, edible oils, sugar and cooking oil | National Family Health Survey to provide data on child anthropometry in affected area | Ex post analysis of the effect of a higher price regime for rice covered by the subsidy programme. Multiple regression used to assess differences in child undernutrition in relation to time in high price regime | Weight-for-age | No evidence for an association between length of time spent in the higher price regime and child nutritional status as assessed by weight-for-age |
Panel B: overnutrition and nutrition-related chronic disease outcomes | |||||||
Veerman et al12 | The Netherlands | European Union withdrawal support policy | Fruit and vegetables | Estimate of fruit and vegetable (tonnes) withdrawn Dietary intake data from national nutrition survey Estimates of national disease frequencies Diet-disease relationship relative risks |
Ex ante models of the effect of a change in dietary intake of fruit and vegetables on disease risks (potential impact fractions) and integrate the changes in disease-specific data into national life tables | Disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) and life expectancy | Removal of fruit and vegetable withdrawal policy would slightly increase fruit and vegetable consumption, reduce the incidence of cardiovascular disease and cancer, reduce the DALYs lost per year and modestly increase life expectancy |
Asfaw15 | Egypt | Egyptian food subsidy programme | Bread, wheat flour, sugar and cooking oil | Integrated Household Survey to provide estimate of household food expenditure (and hence food consumption) and body mass index of mothers | Ex post multiple regression and econometric estimation of effect of food subsidy policy | Body mass index of mothers | Increases in the price of bread and sugar were associated with significant reduction in body mass index of mothers |
Okrent and Alston13 | USA | Farm subsidies on grain commodities | Eight food groups consumed at home, a composite variable for food consumed away from home, and alcoholic beverages | National data on use of farm commodities and retail products Dietary intake data from national nutrition survey Estimated change in weight from change in calorie consumption |
Ex ante equilibrium displacement models of the effect of removal of farm subsidy policy | Adult weight | Removal of existing farm subsidies on grain commodities would result in a modest reduction in weight |