Table 3.
Papers that compared different analgesic methods
Authors | Newborns (n) | Surgical technique | Analgesia |
---|---|---|---|
Banieghbal et al. [18] |
583 |
Gomco |
RB/ RB+milk* |
Lehr et al. [21] |
53 |
Gomco |
DPNB (n=18) /EMLA (n=17) /lidocaine (n=18) |
Lehr et al. [19] |
44 |
Gomco |
DPNB (n=17) /EMLA (n=13) /lidocaine (n=14) |
South et al. [22] |
44 |
Gomco |
DPNB + Tylenol (n=22) /DPNB+Tylenol+non-nutritive sucking (n=22) |
Malnory et al. [24] |
53 |
Gomco |
Acetaminophen (n=26) vs placebo (n=27) |
Macke et al. [27] |
60 |
Gomco |
Acetaminophen (n=29) vs placebo (n=31) |
Kass et al. [29] |
71 |
Gomco |
DPNB (n=24) /dextrose solution (n=23) |
O’Sullivan et al. [17] |
66 |
unknown |
DPNB/fentanyl* |
Garry et al. [20] |
18 |
unknown |
DPNB (n=6) /EMLA (n=6)/ no analgesia (n=6) |
Razmus et al. [23] |
132 |
unknown |
DPNB (n=7) /DPNB+sucrose solution (n=12) / DPNB+sucrose solution+EMLA (n=3) / EMLA(n=6) /EMLA+sucrose solution (n=8) / RB (n=15) / RB+sucrose solution (n=44) / sucrose solution (n=22)/ no analgesia (n=11) |
Joyce et al. [28] | 23 | unknown | EMLA (n=11) / EMLA+music (n=12) |
In bold, the most effective analgesic method. In brackets, the number of babies in each study-group.
*No data was available regarding the number of babies in each study-group.
Abbreviations: RB Ring block, DPNB Dorsal penile nerve block.