Table 2.
Sodium concentrations (mM) calculated from conventional sodium MRI and sodium-inversion recovery MRI for repair tissue, adjacent native cartilage tissue, and native cartilage tissue within the non-surgical compartment (non-surg). P values for comparisons between repair and adjacent native tissue and between native adjacent tissue and native tissue within a non-surgical compartment are shown
|
|
[Na+] in mM
|
[Na+] in mM measured from IR
|
|||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Subject No. | Procedure | Repair | Native adjacent | Native non-surg | Repair | Native adjacent | Native non-surg |
| 1 | Mfx | 174.1 ±15.5 | 154.3 ±4.9 | 168.5 ±10.5 | 135.4 ±9.2 | 194.9 ±12.4 | 234.0 ±17.7 |
| 2 | Mfx | 113.1 ±19.7 | 126.2 ±35.4 | 176.4 ±12.5 | 65.9 ±13.1 | 232.2 ±72.1 | 299.5 ±11.7 |
| 3 | SG | 131.4 ±12.5 | 117.3 ±24.2 | 213.5 ±14.4 | 113.0 ±7.3 | 172.9 ±20.5 | 285.1 ±16.5 |
| 4 | Mfx | 154.3 ±25.5 | 168.4 ±12.7 | 162.5 ±17.9 | 120.5 ±32.3 | 212.2 ±19.5 | 279.7 ±22.8 |
| 5 | JCI | 182.7 ±5.7 | 202.7 ±32.3 | 154.7 ±8.2 | 78.7 ±6.1 | 217.1 ±13.8 | 274.5 ±22.9 |
| 6 | OAllo | 265.6 ±17.5 | 187.0 ±3.4 | 200.8 ±18.9 | 153.8 ±15.7 | 207.2 ±13.4 | 295.3 ±15.8 |
| 7 | SG | 283.9 ±59.1 | 238.7 ±24.1 | 219.3 ±16.6 | 72.6 ±20.1 | 140.9 ±27.3 | 255.2 ±29.0 |
| 8 | OAuto | 190.4 ±57.7 | 156.1 ±24.8 | 125.8 ±34.1 | 94.3 ±35.7 | 201.6 ±48.8 | 257.3 ±24.7 |
| 9 | DFR | 150.9 ±10.5 | 162.5 ±20.5 | 175.3 ±8.1 | 120.8 ±22.4 | 217.8 ±30.3 | 270.7 ±19.7 |
| 10 | Mfx | 126.2 ±14.3 | 173.7 ±19.5 | 168.3 ±21.6 | 96.4 ±19.5 | 141.0 ±8.1 | 136.3 ±22.4 |
| 11 | MACI | 183.8 ±16.4 | 154.2 ±12.6 | 129.6 ±6.1 | 146.7 ±27.7 | 255.4 ±30.8 | 222.0 ±20.0 |
| Mean | 177.8 | 170.1 | 172.2 | 108.9 | 204.6 | 249.8 | |
| Standard deviation | ±54.1 | ±40.7 | ±30.3 | ±29.8 | ±34.7 | ±44.6 | |
| P value: repair vs native adjacent | 0.59 | 0.0000035 | |||||
| P value: native adjacent vs native non-surg | 0.89 | 0.015 | |||||