Table 7.
Summary body weight and body composition
Association of protein/effect (in RCT) | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Number of participants (age) Men (M), Women (W) |
|
Rating A B C |
||||||
Exposure/Intervention | Outcome variable | Study | Total | Animal | Vegetable | Strength of evidence: Convincing, probable, Suggestive, no conclusion | ||
Frequency of protein consumption (per day/per week) | BMI | Cohort (53) | 116 (18–31 years) M and W | NS | NA | NA | C | No conclusion |
Quartiles E% of animal and vegetable protein intake | BMI: risk of overweight obesity | Cohort (54) | 1,730 (40–55 years) M | NA NA |
POS POS |
NS INVERSE |
C | |
High protein diet (HP): 1.9 g/kg BW (22 E%) vs. | BMI | Randomized controlled trial (59) | 15 (18–36 years) M | NS | NA | NA | C | |
Normal diet (NP): < 1.3 g/kg BW (15 E%) in 6 months | ||||||||
High protein diet (HP): 1.9 g/kg BW (22 E%) vs. | Body weight change | Randomized controlled trial (59) | 15 (18–36 years) M | INVERSE | NA | NA | C | No conclusion |
Normal diet (NP): < 1.3 g/kg BW (15 E%) in 6 months | ||||||||
Total, animal and vegetable protein in kcal/day and per 150 kcal/day increments (equal 37.5 g protein) | Change in body weight in gram per year | 6 cohorts (56) | 89,432 M and W | POS | POS | NS | B | |
Protein E% | 5-yr change in body weight | Cohort (57) | 1,762 M and W | NS | NA | NA | B | |
Protein intake in servings/day | Weight gain of > 10 lb, yes or no | Cohort (58) | 336 W | NS | NA | NA | C | |
15 E% protein vs. 30 E% | Body weight change | Controlled trial (52) | 19 M and W | INVERSE | NA | NA | B | |
E% of total, animal. and vegetable protein | 5-y change in waist circumference | Cohort (55) | 42,969 M and W | INVERSE | INVERSE | NS | B | No conclusion |
Total, animal and vegetable protein in kcal/day and per 150 kcal/day increments (equal 37.5 g protein) | 6.5-y-change in waist circumference | Cohort (56) | 89,432 M and W | NS | NS | NS | B | |
High protein diet (HP): 1.9 g/kg BW (22 E%) vs. | Body composition: | Randomized controlled trial (59) | 15 (18–36 years) M | C | No conclusion | |||
Normal diet (NP): < 1.3 g/kg BW (15 E%) in 6 months | FFM (kg) FM (kg) |
NS NS |
NA NA |
NA NA |