Skip to main content
. 2013 Jul 10;4(4):499–507. doi: 10.1007/s13244-013-0264-6

Table 1.

Model input parameters

Model parameter Mean SE/SD/rangea Distribution Source
  Discount rates
    cDR (cost discount rate) 4 % fixed [21]
    oDR (outcome discount rate) 1.5 % fixed [21]
Treatment independent parameters
    Probabilities, (p)
    pAneurysm in case of non-traumatic SAH 0.85 fixed [14]
Costs, c (€)
  Diagnostics
    cDSA 725 € fixed [21]
    cMRA 252 € fixed [21]
    cCTA 197 € fixed [21]
  Treatment
    cCoiling 38,238 € 1,833 € gamma [10]
    cClipping 31,739 € 2,503 € gamma [10]
  Health state costs
    Number of days in nursing home per year (d) 365
    Costs per day in nursing home (euros/d) 241 €
    cDisability 87,975 € [21]
  Event costs
    cDeath 2,741 € [18, 23]
Utilities (u)
    uWell 0.78 0.019 beta [18, 22]
    uWell after SAH 0.72 0.65–0.80 triangular [18, 22]
    uDisabled 0.25 0.21–0.30 triangular [18, 22]
    uDead 0.00 fixed [18, 22]
Clinical outcome probabilities
    Probability of being well after clipping 0.69 0.014 beta [7]
    Probability of being disabled after clipping 0.21 0.013 beta [7]
    pClipdead (probability of being dead after clipping) 0.10 0.009 beta [7]
    pClipwell (probability of being well after survived clipping) 0.77 [7]
    Probability of being well after coiling 0.76 0.013 beta [7]
    Probability of being disabled after coiling 0.16 0.011 beta [7]
    pCoildead (probability of being dead after coiling) 0.08 0.008 beta [7]
    pCoilwell (probability of being well after survived coiling) 0.83 [7]
    Probability of being well after DSA 0.998 0.001 beta [17, 24]
    Probability of being disabled after DSA 0.002 0.001 beta [17, 24]
    pDSAdead (probability of being dead after DSA) 0.000 fixed [17, 24]
    pDSAwell (probability of being well after survived DSA) 0.998
    Probability of being dead/disabled after surgery without aneurysm
    pSurgdead 0.025 0.004 beta [30]
    pSurgdisab 0.132 0.008 beta [30]
    pCoilTP (probability coiling is feasible in true-positive aneurysm) 0.585 0.061 beta [19]
    pCoilFP (probability coiling is feasible in false-positive aneurysm) 0 fixed [19]
Treatment dependent parameters Value SE/SD/rangea Distribution Source
  Probabilities
    pMRAtpD (sensitivity of MRA in diagnosing aneurysm) 0.954 0.018 beta [19]
    pMRAtnD (specificity of MRA in diagnosing aneurysm) 0.833 0.061 beta [19]
    pCTAtpD (sensitivity of CTA in diagnosing aneurysm) 0.915 0.024 beta [19]
    pCTAtnD (specificity of CTA in diagnosing aneurysm) 0.944 0.038 beta [19]
    pMRAtpT (sensitivity of MRA in determining whether coiling is feasible) 0.606 0.058 beta b
    pMRAtnT (specificity of MRA in determining whether coiling is feasible) 0.814 0.050 beta b
    pCTAtpT (sensitivity of CTA in determining whether coiling is feasible) 0.719 0.056 beta b
    pCTAtnT (specificity of CTA in determining whether coiling is feasible) 0.754 0.057 beta b
    pDSAtpD (sensitivity of DSA in diagnosing aneurysm) 1 fixed [19]
    pDSAtnD (Specificity DSA in diagnosing aneurysm) 1 fixed [19]
    pDSAtpT (sensitivity of DSA in determining whether coiling is feasible) 1 fixed [19]
    pDSAtnT (specificity of DSA in determining whether coiling is feasible) 1 fixed [19]

aRange presented for triangular distributions

bData based on study [19]