Skip to main content
. 2013 Aug 5;8(8):e71955. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0071955

Table 3. Study Characteristics (RADIOTHERAPY).

Author (Year) Country Study Follow-up Patient Characteristics Radiotherapy Implant Characteristics QS
Mean Age CON/STY F Time Dose (Gy) CON/STY Position (Mand./Max.) FC/FS
Esser, 1997 Germany Prospec NA (37–79 yr) NA/NA 9 BP 60 66/152 Mandible 7/33 7
Werkmeister, 1999 Germany Retro 3 yrs 55 yr 17/12 6 BP 54 79/30 Local: 64/Grafted: 45 19/8 7
Keller, 1999 USA Retro 12 yrs (15–73 yr) 52/2 NA NA 55 and 61 237/11 Grafted maxilla 33/0 10
Shaw, 2005 UK Retro 3.5 yr 58 yr 43/34 32 BP 40–66 192/172 Local: 238/Grafted: 126 25/31 9
Yerit, 2006 Austria Prospec 5.4±3.2 yr 58±14 yr NA/NA 15 BP 50 162/154 Local: 238/Grafted: 78 15/29 9
Schepers, 2006 Netherlands Retro up to 23 m 66.11 yr 27/21 19 AP 60–68 78/61 NA 0/2 8
Landes, 2006 Germany Prospec 36 m 63 yr 11/19 8 BP 57 42/72 NA 0/1 8
Nelson, 2007 Germany Prospec 10.3 yr 59 yr NA/29 30 BP up to 72 311/124 281/154 4/7 7
Alsaadi, 2008 Belgium Retro 2 yr NA 410/2 240 NA NA 1,499/15 698/816 98/3 8
Schoen, 2008 Netherlands Prospec 12 m 62±11 yr 16/19 15 AP 60.1±7.7 64/76 Local bone 2/2 9
Klein, 2009 Germany Retro 5 yr 58.4 yr 16/27 12 BP <50 or ≥50 74/116 Local: 62/Grafted: 128 12/13 8
Cuesta-Gil, 2009 Spain Prospec / 52 yr 32/79 31 Mixed 50–60 311/395 Local: 454/Grafted: 252 6/75 9
Salinas, 2010 USA Retro 41.1 NA 18/26 19 Mixed > 60 116/90 Local: 105/Flap: 114 8/23 10
Linsen, 2012 Germany Prospec 48±34.3 m 56±16 yr 32/34 23 BP 36 or 60 135/127 213/49 6/8 10
Jacobsen, 2012 Switzerland Retro 67 m 52.4 yr NA/NA 16 AP NA 93/47 Local: 41/Flap: 99 14/14 9
Fenlon, 2012 UK Retro / NA 29/12 NA AP 66 110/35 Grafted bone 3/15 8

CON = control group,that is non-radiotherapy group; STY = study group, that is radiotherapy group; F = Female; BP = before placement; AP = after placement; Mand. = mandible; Max. = maxilla; Retro = retrospective study; Prospec = prospective study; yr = year; m = month; NA = not available,; Local = local bone; Grafted = grafted bone; FC = failure implant number of Control Group; FS = failure implant number of Study Group; QS = quality assessment score.