Table 5.
Reported validity of plain radiographs measurements compared with CT measurements for anteversion
Study | Method for measuring anteversion | Definition of anteversion measured on CT | Referenced coronal plane of CT | Mean error ± SD |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ghelman et al. [6] | Woo’s method from cross-table lateral radiographs | Radiographic anteversion | Radiographic coronal plane | 8.7° (range, −10.7° to 25°) |
Hassan et al. [8] | Hassan’s method from AP radiographs | Not known (true measurements in vitro) | Not known (true measurements in vitro) | −2.5° (range, −0.8° to −3.4°) |
Marx et al. [17] | AP radiographs for all: | Radiographic anteversion for all | APP for all | |
McLaren’s method | −14.5° ± 10.5° | |||
Ackland’s method | −14.3° ± 10.3° | |||
Pradhan’s method | −14.5° ± 10.2° | |||
Widmer’s method | −6.4° ± 10.8° | |||
Hassan’s method | −14.4° ± 10.2° | |||
Nho et al. [20] | AP radiographs | Anatomic anteversion | Radiographic coronal plane | Not known |
Current study | Lewinneck’s method from AP radiographs | Radiographic anteversion | Radiographic coronal plane | 0.55° ± 3.14° |