Skip to main content
. 2013 Aug 8;9(8):e1003690. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgen.1003690

Table 2. Theoretical predictions of the genomic location of sex-biased genes in aphids.

Theoretical predictions: Empirical test of Predictions 3: Genomic location of sex-biased genes
Predictions 1: Preferred location for mutations with antagonistic effects (based on the analytical model and on our simulations) Predictions 2: Expression pattern of sexually antagonist mutations after the evolution of modifiers of gene expression Predictions 3: Combination of Predictions 1 and 2 Random expectations: All genes: #X∶#A = 497∶3215, f (X) = 0.13Genes with >5 reads: #X∶#A = 390∶2930, f (X) = 0.12
Fitness effect of the mutation threshold for expression bias #X∶#A f(X) % deviation X2 test P-value
sm>0, sf<0, sa<0 X M+F−A− M+F−A−: enriched on the X 2-fold 63∶205 0.24 +100% <10−8
5-fold 54∶118 0.31 +167% <10−14
10-fold 44∶87 0.34 +186% <10−14
sm>0, sf>0, sa<0 X M+F+A− M+F+A−: enriched on the X 2-fold 6∶17 0.26 +122% 0.033
5-fold 6∶6 0.50 +326% 0.0001
10-fold 4∶3 0.57 +386% 0.0002
sm<0, sf>0, sa>0 A M−F−A+ M−F−A+: depleted on the X 2-fold 11∶153 0.07 −43% 0.045
5-fold 4∶104 0.04 −68% 0.009
10-fold 3∶81 0.04 −70% 0.020
sm<0, sf>0, sa>0 A M−F+A+ M−F+A+: depleted on the X 2-fold 2∶69 0.03 −76% 0.019
5-fold 1∶21 0.05 −61% 0.29
10-fold 1∶12 0.08 −35% 0.65
sm<0, sf>0, sa<0 Slight bias towards A M−F+A− M−F+A−: slight bias towards A 2-fold 19∶193 0.09 −24% 0.21
5-fold 8∶72 0.10 −15% 0.63
10-fold 3∶40 0.07 −41% 0.33
sm>0, sf<0, sa>0 Slight bias towards X M+F−A+ M+F−A+: slight bias towards X 2-fold 7∶73 0.09 −26% 0.41
5-fold 3∶51 0.06 −53% 0.16
10-fold 2∶22 0.08 −29% 0.60

The preferred chromosomal locations of sexually antagonistic mutations (Prediction 1) are based on the simulations presented in Figure 2. Prediction 2: Predicted evolution of expression pattern of a gene bearing a sexually antagonist mutation after the evolution of a modifier that reduces the expression in the harmed sex (M, F and A refer to male, sexual female and asexual female, respectively, and the sign represents relative expression in each morph). The genomic locations of sex-biased genes (Predictions 3) were obtained by combining Predictions1 and 2. Theoretical predictions 3 were then tested with empirical data by looking at the genomic location of sex-biased genes, when considering different levels of fold-change in expression (2-, 5-, 10-fold difference). Observed number of genes for X and autosomes, frequency of X-linkage, % deviation from random expectation of X-linkage (f (X) = 0.12) and its significance (Chi-square tests) are also given.