Skip to main content
. 2013 Aug 12;8(8):e71910. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0071910

Table 2. Quality assessment of included studies.

randomization concealed allocation blinding incomplete outcome data selective reporting other biases Qi
Cao 2012 mentioned unclear unclear unclear unclear unclear 0.75
Chew 2010 mentioned yes, sealed opaque envelopes no unclear unclear yes, conflict of interest 0.83
Eschertzhuber 2012 mentioned unclear yes unclear unclear unclear 0.92
Li 2011 yes, random number unclear unclear unclear unclear unclear 0.75
Ragazzi 2012 yes, random number unclear unclear unclear unclear unclear 0.83
Russo 2012 yes, random number yes, sealed opaque envelopes unclear unclear unclear no 0.83
Teoh 2010 yes, random number yes, sealed opaque envelopes blinded to patients unclear unclear yes, conflict of interest 0.96
Theiler 2009 yes, random number unclear blinded to operators unclear unclear yes, conflict of interest 0.88
Van Zundert 2012 yes, random number yes, sealed opaque envelopes blinded to observer unclear unclear unclear 0.96
Yu 2011 yes, random number unclear unclear unclear unclear unclear 0.83