Table 4. Mean cost and effect differences between the SHARP and CAU group.
| Analysisa | ΔC (95% CI) | ΔE (95% CI) | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| euros | percentage/days/eurosd | ICER | NMBe | ||||
| Total group | |||||||
| CEA-incidence of RSA | 1932 (-318 to 5350) | 0.24 (0.03 to 0.45) | 10605 | ||||
| CEA-time to RSA | 1358 (-945 to 4886) | 55 (2.85 to 106.09) | 2183 | ||||
| CBA HCA only sickness absence | 800 (678 to 922) | 5246 (-2701 to 13192) | 6046 | ||||
| CBA FCA only sickness absence | 800 (678 to 922) | 3195 (-2214 to 8604) | 3995 | ||||
| CBA HCA combinedb | 800 (678 to 922) | 4730 (-5699 to 15158) | 5530 | ||||
| CBA FCA combinedb | 800 (678 to 922) | 3929 (-3764 to 11623) | 4729 | ||||
| Excluding outlierc | |||||||
| CEA-incidence of RSA | -133 (-1155 to 914) | 0.25 (0.03 to 0.46) | -533 | ||||
| CEA-time to RSA | -129 (-1266 to 964) | 59 (5.95 to 111.15) | -2 | ||||
CEA = cost effectiveness analysis; RSA = recurrent sickness absence; CBA = cost benefit analysis; ΔC = mean cost difference; ΔE = mean effect difference; HCA = human capital approach; FCA = friction cost approach; ICER = incremental cost effect ration; NMB = net monetary benefit
In the CEA, ΔC is the mean difference in total health care costs and ΔE is the mean difference in percentage of workers that experienced recurrent sickness absence; in the CBA, ΔC is the mean difference in total occupational health care costs, including the intervention, for the employer and ΔE is the mean difference in sickness absence costs estimated by the HCA or FCA.
Productivity loss costs are a combination of sickness absence costs and costs due to lost productivity at work.
Sensitivity analysis excluding one extreme outlier.
Differences in CEA effects are presented in (1) percentage of workers that experienced recurrent sickness absence, (2) number of days to recurrent sickness absence; differences in CBA effects are presented as costs in euros.
Negative values of the NMB imply lower costs for the intervention group compared to the control group.