Skip to main content
. 2004 Feb 23;101(9):2673–2677. doi: 10.1073/pnas.0308730100

Table 1. MADs (all energies in eV) for various level of theory for the extended G2 set.

G2(MAD)
Method ΔHf IP EA PA H-Ne, Etot TM ΔE He2, ΔE(Re) Ne2, ΔE(Re) (H2O)2, De(RO...O)
HF 6.47 1.036 1.158 0.15 4.49 1.09 Unbound Unbound 0.161 (3.048)
G2 or best ab initio 0.07a 0.053b 0.057b 0.05b 1.59c 0.19d 0.0011 (2.993)e 0.0043 (3.125)e 0.218 (2.912)f
LDA (SVWN) 3.94a 0.665 0.749 0.27 6.67 0.54g 0.0109 (2.377) 0.0231 (2.595) 0.391 (2.710)
GGA
   BP86 0.88a 0.175 0.212 0.05 0.19 0.46 Unbound Unbound 0.194 (2.889)
   BLYP 0.31a 0.187 0.106 0.08 0.19 0.37g Unbound Unbound 0.181 (2.952)
   BPW91 0.34a 0.163 0.094 0.05 0.16 0.60 Unbound Unbound 0.156 (2.946)
   PW91PW91 0.77 0.164 0.141 0.06 0.35 0.52 0.0100 (2.645) 0.0137 (3.016) 0.235 (2.886)
   mPWPWh 0.65 0.161 0.122 0.05 0.16 0.38 0.0052 (2.823) 0.0076 (3.178) 0.194 (2.911)
   PBEPBEi 0.74i 0.156 0.101 0.06 1.25 0.34 0.0032 (2.752) 0.0048 (3.097) 0.222 (2.899)
   XLYPj 0.33 0.186 0.117 0.09 0.95 0.24 0.0010 (2.805) 0.0030 (3.126) 0.192 (2.953)
Hybrid methods
   BH & HLYPk 0.94 0.207 0.247 0.07 0.08 0.72 Unbound Unbound 0.214 (2.905)
   B3P86l 0.78a 0.636 0.593 0.03 2.80 0.34 Unbound Unbound 0.206 (2.878)
   B3LYPm 0.13a 0.168 0.103 0.06 0.38 0.25g Unbound Unbound 0.198 (2.926)
   B3PW91n 0.15a 0.161 0.100 0.03 0.24 0.38 Unbound Unbound 0.175 (2.923)
   PW1PWo 0.23 0.160 0.114 0.04 0.30 0.30 0.0066 (2.660) 0.0095 (3.003) 0.227 (2.884)
   mPW1PWp 0.17 0.160 0.118 0.04 0.16 0.31 0.0020 (3.052) 0.0023 (3.254) 0.199 (2.898)
   PBE1PBEq 0.21i 0.162 0.126 0.04 1.09 0.30 0.0018 (2.818) 0.0026 (3.118) 0.216 (2.896)
   O3LYPr 0.18 0.139 0.107 0.05 0.06 0.49 0.0031 (2.860) 0.0047 (3.225) 0.139 (3.095)
   X3LYPs 0.12 0.154 0.087 0.07 0.11 0.22 0.0010 (2.726) 0.0028 (2.904) 0.216 (2.908)
   Experimental 0.0010 (2.970)t 0.0036 (3.091)t 0.236u (2.948)v

ΔHf, heat of formation at 298 K; PA, proton affinity; Etot, total energies (H-Ne); TM ΔE, s to d excitation energy of nine first-row transition metal atoms and nine positive ions. Bonding properties [ΔE or De in eV and (Re) in Å] are given for He2, Ne2, and (H2O)2. The best DFT results are in boldface, as are the most accurate answers [experiment except for (H2O)2].

a

Ref. 5

b

Ref. 19

c

Ref. 4

d

Ref. 35

e

Ref. 38

f

Ref. 34

g

Ref. 37

h

Ref. 7

i

Ref. 10

j

1.0 Ex (Slater) + 0.722 ΔEx (B88) + 0.347 ΔEx (PW91) + 1.0 Ec (LYP)

k

0.5 Ex (HF) + 0.5 Ex (Slater) + 0.5 ΔEx (B88) + 1.0 Ec (LYP)

l

0.20 Ex (HF) + 0.80 Ex (Slater) + 0.72 ΔEx (B88) + 1.0 Ec (VWN) + 0.81 ΔEc (P86)

m

0.20 Ex (HF) + 0.80 Ex (Slater) + 0.72 ΔEx (B88) + 0.19 Ec (VWN) + 0.81 Ec (LYP)

n

0.20 Ex (HF) + 0.80 Ex (Slater) + 0.72 ΔEx (B88) + 1.0 Ec (PW91, local) + 0.81 ΔEc (PW91, nonlocal)

o

0.25 Ex (HF) + 0.75 Ex (Slater) + 0.75 ΔEx (PW91) + 1.0 Ec (PW91)

p

0.25 Ex (HF) + 0.75 Ex (Slater) + 0.75 ΔEx (mPW) + 1.0 Ec (PW91)

q

0.25 Ex (HF) + 0.75 Ex (Slater) + 0.75 ΔEx (PBE) + 1.0 Ec (PW91, local) + 1.0 ΔEc (PBE, nonlocal)

r

0.1161 Ex (HF) + 0.9262 Ex (Slater) + 0.8133 ΔEx (OPTX) + 0.19 Ec (VWNS) + 0.81 Ec (LYP)

s

0.218 Ex (HF) + 0.782 Ex (Slater) + 0.542 ΔEx (B88) + 0.167 ΔEx (PW91) + 0.129 Ec (VWN) + 0.871 Ec (LYP)

t

Ref. 27

u

Ref. 33

v

Ref. 32