Table 4. Summary of studies showing toxicity after high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy combined with external beam radiotherapy.
Reference | Sample size | Genitourinary toxicity | Gastrointestinal toxicity | Erectile dysfunction | Follow-up (months) |
Borghede et al [50] | n=50 | 8% G3 | 0% G3 | 10% | 45 |
Mate et al [58] | n=104 | 6.7% urethral stricture | |||
Kestin et al [31] | n=161 | 5% G3, 0% G4 | 29% | 36 | |
4% urethral stricture | |||||
Syed et al [61] | n=200 | 20% G3, 10% G4, late 2% G3 | 1.5% | 30% | 30 |
1.5% urethral stricture | |||||
<1% urinary incontinence | |||||
Deger et al [35] | n=230 | 12.2% G3 and 4 | 1.7% recto-urethral fistula | 40 | |
7.4% urethral strictures | |||||
3% G2–3 urinary incontinence | |||||
Galalae et al [52] | n=144 | 2.3% G3 | 4.1% G3 | 96 | |
Martinez et al [44] | n=207 | 8% G3, 0% G4 | 0.5% G3, 0.5% G4 | 51% | 60 |
1.4% urethral stricture | |||||
Martin et al [56] | n=2004 | 5% G3 | 1% G3 | 32 | |
Hiratsuka et al [53] | n=71 | 6% urethral structure | 44 | ||
Aström et al [34] | n=214 | 17% transient haematuria | 0% G3 | 14% | 48 |
7% urethral stricture | |||||
Demanes et al [37] | n=209 | 6.7% G3, 1% G4 | 0% | 33% | 120 |
6.7% urethral stricture | |||||
3.8% urinary incontinence | |||||
Izard et al [43] | n=165 | 3% G3, 1.4% G4 | 2.6% G3, 0% G4 | 39% | 60 |
1.2% urinary incontinence | |||||
Yamada et al [47] | n=105 | 47% | 60 | ||
Chin et al [51] | n=65 | 4.6% G3 | 0% | 42 | |
6.2% G3, 1.5% G4 | |||||
4.6% urethral stricture | |||||
Flynn et al [38] | n=674 | 2.5% and 15.8% urinary incontinence without and with previous TURP | 0% | 35% at 1 year, 40% at 2 years | 60 |
Guix et al [41] | n=445 | 17.2% G2 | 21.6% G2 | 60 | |
Phan et al [46] | n=309 | 4% G3 | 1% G3 | 38% | 60 |
1% urinary incontinence | |||||
4.5% urethral stricture | |||||
Rades et al [59] | n=41 | No G3 early or late toxicity | 24–35% | ||
Kalkner et al [55] | n=154 | 4% G3 | 1% G3 | 72 | |
Sato et al [60] | n=53 | 0% G2 | 3.8% G2 | 22.6% | 60 |
Zwahlen et al [62] | n=196 | 7.1% G3 | 0% G3 | 66 | |
No G4 toxicity | |||||
Hsu et al [54] | n=112 | 2.6% G3 | 3.6% G3 | 27.7% | 30 |
0.9% urethral stricture | |||||
0.9% urinary incontinence | |||||
Martinez et al [57] | n=472 | 2–3% G3 | <0.5% G3 | 120 | |
Agoston et al [36] | n=280 | 14.4% G3 | 2.1% G3 | 60 | |
29.1% G3 previous TURP |
G, grade; TURP, transurethral resection of prostate.