Table 3.
Response Modality/Imagery Scene | Control | PTSD | Group Effect |
---|---|---|---|
Pleasure (1–9) | |||
Neutral | 6.93 (1.53) | 6.41 (1.74) | F(1,121) = 3.04, ns |
Anger | 2.79 (1.22)a | 2.59 (1.14)a | F(1,121) = .90, ns |
Panic attack | 4.00 (1.08)a | 3.49 (1.49)a | F(1,121) = 4.82, p < .05 |
Survival threat | 2.68 (.99)a | 2.59 (1.36)a | F(1,121) = .20, ns |
Personal/idiographic threat | 2.65 (1.41)a | 1.62 (1.11)a | F(1,119) = 17.99, p < .001 |
Arousal (1–9) | |||
Neutral | 2.31 (1.54) | 3.10 (1.78) | F(1,121) = 6.81, p < .05 |
Anger | 6.15 (1.78)a | 6.73 (1.71)a | F(1,121) = 3.22, p < .05b |
Panic attack | 5.37 (1.90)a | 6.88 (1.44)a | F(1,121) = 21.80, p < .001 |
Survival threat | 6.69 (1.53)a | 6.99 (1.70)a | F(1,121) = 1.00, ns |
Personal/idiographic threat | 7.69 (1.67)a | 8.12 (1.66)a | F(1,119) = 1.93, ns |
Startle Reflex (t score) | |||
Neutral | 49.76 (5.01) | 52.16 (10.78) | F(1,107) = 2.50, ns |
Anger | 51.16 (6.08) | 56.34 (15.56)a | F(1,107) = 5.54, p < .05 |
Panic attack | 51.51 (7.20)a | 55.30 (9.53)a | F(1,107) = 5.53, p < .05 |
Survival threat | 54.57 (8.22)a | 57.42 (13.80)a | F(1,107) = 1.83, ns |
Personal/idiographic threat | 53.58 (7.33)a | 59.37 (24.86)a | F(1,107) = 3.24, p < .05b |
SCL Δ (log [μS + 1]) | |||
Neutral | −.006 (.036) | −.013 (.061) | F(1,118) = 4.87, p < .05 |
Anger | .0005 (.035) | .012 (.048) | F(1,119) = 2.52, ns |
Panic attack | .0009 (.042) | .011 (.067) | F(1,117) = .98, ns |
Survival threat | .004 (.022)a | .031 (.089)a | F(1,118) = 6.30, p < .05 |
Personal/idiographic threat | .045 (.086)a | .063 (.145)a | F(1,118) = .79, ns |
Heart Rate Δ (bpm) | |||
Neutral | −.46 (2.03) | −.95 (2.04) | F(1,120) = 1.68, ns |
Anger | −.27 (1.43) | −.68 (1.37) | F(1,120) = 2.49, ns |
Panic attack | −.22 (1.50) | .20 (1.62)a | F(1,121) = 2.40, ns |
Survival threat | .04 (1.00)a | –.29 (1.12)a | F(1,121) = 3.02, ns |
Personal/idiographic threat | 1.00 (1.00)a | 2.02 (3.07)a | F(1,120) = 4.56, p < .05 |
Corrugator EMG Δ (μV) | |||
Neutral | −.07 (.79) | .18 (1.71) | F(1,122) = 1.19, ns |
Anger | 1.17 (2.77)a | .80 (1.67)a | F(1,122) = .72, ns |
Panic attack | .49 (1.40)a | .60 (1.24)a | F(1,122) = .19, ns |
Survival threat | .96 (1.98)a | 1.34 (2.10)a | F(1,122) = 1.05, ns |
Personal/idiographic threat | 1.17 (2.60)a | 2.66 (5.15)a | F(1,122) = 4.52, p < .05 |
Note: Pleasure rated on SAM (50): 1 = completely unhappy, 9 = completely happy; Arousal rated on SAM: 1 = completely relaxed, 9 = completely aroused.
Δ, change; bpm, residual beats per minute after removal of baseline effects; EMG, electromyographic; μS, microsiemen; μV, microvolt; PTSD, posttraumatic stress disorder; SAM, Self-Assessment Manikin; SCL, skin conductance level.
Within-group comparison to neutral significant at p < .05.
One-tailed test.