Table 2. Studies included in the systematic review and meta-analysis.
Ref # | Author | Year | Years Conducted | Country | Study Sample Size | Study Type | Setting | Urban or Rural | Timing of EOS Diagnosis | Antibiotic Use | Specialized Population | WHO Regiona | Neonatal Mortality Rate (per 1,000 Live Births) | Income (USD) |
96 | Barcaite | 2012 | 2006–2007 | Lithuania | 998 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | EUR | 3 | 11,390 |
26 | Chemsi | 2012 | 2009–2011 | Morocco | 99 | Case-control | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Unknown | All | EMR | 20 | 2,850 |
28 | Emamghorashi | 2012 | 2010 | Iran | 114 | Case-control | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | EMR | 19 | 2,500 |
100 | Huang | 2012 | 2005 | Taiwan | 92 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | WPR | 4 | 41,385 |
29 | Kovo | 2012 | 2007–2009 | Israel | 120 | Case-control | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | EUR | 2 | 27,170 |
47 | Lee | 2012 | 2005–2010 | Hong Kong | 212 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | WPR | 1 | 51,490 |
62 | Tudela | 2012 | 2000–2008 | USA | 143,384 | Cohort | Multi-center | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
64 | Wojkowska | 2012 | 2009 | Poland | 910 | Cohort | Multi-center | Urban | >7 days | Used | All | EUR | 4 | 12,440 |
66 | Kordek | 2011 | n/a | Poland | 286 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | EUR | 4 | 12,440 |
75 | Kunze | 2011 | Jan–Dec 2004 | Germany | 869 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | EUR | 2 | 43,110 |
57 | Puopolo | 2011 | 1993–2007 | USA | 1,413 | Nested case-control | Multi-center | Unknown | ≤7 days | Used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
99 | Bourgeois-Nicolaos | 2010 | Jan 2004–Dec 2004 | France | 1,139 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | EUR | 2 | 42,390 |
56 | Dutta | 2010 | n/a | India | 728 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | Preterm | SEAR | 34 | 1,330 |
74 | Faro | 2010 | Jan 2003–Dec 2004 | USA | 2,108 | Cohort | Multi-center | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
48 | Kasper | 2010 | June 2001 | Austria | 118 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | Preterm | EUR | 2 | 47,060 |
95 | Seoud | 2010 | Feb 2004–Sep 2004 | Lebanon | 779 | Cohort | Multi-center | Urban | >7 days | Used | All | EMR | 7 | 8,880 |
101 | Tameliene | 2010 | 2006–2007 | Lithuania | 970 | Cohort | Health facility | Unknown | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | EUR | 3 | 11,390 |
94 | Elzbieta | 2009 | Jan 2008–Mar 2008 | Poland | 100 | Cohort | Health facility | Unknown | ≤7 days | Used | All | EUR | 4 | 12,440 |
98 | Pinter | 2009 | Jun–Dec 2005 | USA | 317 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
31 | Andrews | 2008 | Jul 2003–Jun 2006 | USA | 5,732 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
46 | Goldenberg | 2008 | 1996–2001 | USA | 351 | Cohort | Health facility | Unknown | ≤7 days | Unknown | Preterm | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
73 | Namavar Jahromi | 2008 | Apr–Sep 2003 | Iran | 1,197 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | EMR | 19 | 2,500 |
93 | Lijoi | 2007 | Nov 2003–Nov 2004 | Italy | 2,158 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Not used | All | EUR | 2 | 35,150 |
21 | Muthusami | 2007 | May 2006–Jul 2006 | India | 77 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | SEAR | 34 | 1,330 |
17 | Kalinka | 2006 | May 2001–Dec 2002 | Poland | 120 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Not used | All | EUR | 4 | 12,440 |
65 | Kordek | 2006 | n/a | Poland | 46 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | Preterm or PROM | EUR | 4 | 12,440 |
19 | Kunze | 2006 | Jan 2011–Dec 2002 | Germany | 1,438 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | EUR | 2 | 43,110 |
92 | Eren | 2005 | May 2000–Jan 2001 | Turkey | 500 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | Other | EUR | 12 | 9,890 |
55 | Ronnestad | 2005 | 1999–2000 | Norway | 119,611 | Cohort | Multi-center | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | Preterm | EUR | 2 | 84,290 |
102 | Kafetzis | 2004 | Jun 2000–Dec 2001 | Greece | 251 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | EUR | 2 | 26,940 |
91 | Tsolia | 2003 | Jan 2000–May 2000 | Greece | 1,014 | Cohort | Multi-center | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | EUR | 2 | 26,940 |
63 | Dollner | 2002 | 1999 | Norway | 221 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | EUR | 2 | 84,290 |
90 | El-Kersh | 2002 | Jan 1963–Jul 1965 | Saudi Arabia | 217 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Not used | All | EMR | 12 | 16,720 |
30 | Oddie | 2002 | Apr 1988–Mar 2000 | UK | 62,786 | Case-control | Multi-center | Unknown | ≤7 days | Used | All | EUR | 3 | 38,370 |
24 | Vergani | 2002 | 1991–1994 | USA | 32,630 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Not used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
80 | Volumenie | 2001 | Jan 1994–Sep 1996 | France | 5,374 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Used | All | EUR | 2 | 42,390 |
78 | Ma | 2000 | Dec 1997–Dec 1998 | China | 768 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | WPR | 11 | 4,270 |
45 | Yoon | 2000 | n/a | South Korea | 315 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | Preterm | WPR | 2 | 17,890 |
27 | Cukrowska | 1999 | n/a | Czech Republic | 148 | Case-control | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | Preterm | EUR | 2 | 17,890 |
89 | Hickman | 1999 | Jan 1994–Feb 1995 | USA | 546 | Cohort | Multi-center | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
61 | Mercer | 1999 | Jul 1997–Feb 1998 | USA | 8,474 | Cohort | Multi-center | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
72 | Piper | 1999 | Jan 1992–Jun 1994 | USA | 1,046 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
25 | Bhutta | 1997 | Jan 1990–Dec 1993 | Pakistan | 38 | Case-control | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | EMR | 42 | 1,050 |
79 | Mercer | 1997 | Feb 1992–Jan 1995 | USA | 1,867 | Cohort | Multi-center | Unknown | ≤7 days | Not used | PPROM | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
54 | Papantoniou | 1997 | Feb 1993–Jun 1994 | Greece | 32 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Used | PPROM | EUR | 2 | 26,940 |
88 | Sensini | 1997 | Mar 1993–Sep 1995 | Italy | 2,300 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | EUR | 2 | 35,150 |
77 | Itakura | 1996 | Jul 1987–Dec 1992 | Japan | 1,280 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | WPR | 1 | 41,850 |
97 | Mitsuda | 1996 | Jul 1991–Jun 1992 | Japan | 466 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | WPR | 1 | 41,850 |
71 | Regan | 1996 | 1984–1989 | USA | 13,646 | Cohort | Multi-center | Urban | >7 days | Not used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
43 | Averbuch | 1995 | n/a | Israel | 90 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Unknown | PPROM | EUR | 2 | 27,170 |
44 | Matsuda | 1995 | Feb–Oct 1992 | Japan | 41 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Unknown | Preterm | WPR | 1 | 41,850 |
60 | Rosemond | 1995 | Jun 1989–Dec 1993 | USA | 224 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Used | PPROM | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
86 | Ayata | 1994 | n/a | Turkey | 114 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | EUR | 12 | 9,890 |
53 | de Araujo | 1994 | 1991 | Brazil | 223 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | AMR | 12 | 9,390 |
42 | Gauthier | 1994 | n/a | USA | 225 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Not used | PPROM | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
16 | Pylipow | 1994 | Jan 1991–Sep 1992 | USA | 2,040 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
87 | Suara | 1994 | May 1992–Feb 1993 | Gambia | 196 | Cohort | Health facility | Unknown | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | AFR | 32 | 7,740 |
52 | Puchner | 1993 | n/a | Austria | 80 | Cohort | Unknown | Unknown | >7 days | Not used | All | EUR | 2 | 47,060 |
70 | Burman | 1992 | n/a | Sweden | 4,559 | Cohort | Multi-center | Unknown | >7 days | Not used | All | EUR | 2 | 50,110 |
6 | Ayengar | 1991 | n/a | India | 1,792 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | SEAR | 34 | 1,330 |
51 | Dudley | 1991 | Feb 1988–Jul 1990 | Australia | 81 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | PPROM | WPR | 3 | 46,320 |
69 | Towers | 1990 | Jan 1989–Jul 1989 | USA | 131 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Used | Preterm or PROM | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
85 | Kollee | 1989 | Apr 1986–Jan 1987 | Netherlands | 632 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | EUR | 3 | 49,050 |
20 | Morales | 1989 | Jan 1 1986–Mar 1988 | USA | 212 | Cohort | Multi-center | Urban | >7 days | Not used | PPROM | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
59 | Newton | 1989 | Apr–Dec 1986 | USA | 2,908 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
23 | Tuppurainen | 1989 | Dec 1983–Jan 1986 | Finland | 8,977 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Not used | All | EUR | 2 | 47,720 |
18 | Kishore | 1987 | n/a | India | 109 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Not used | All | SEAR | 34 | 1,330 |
41 | Feinstein | 1986 | Jul 1983–Apr 1985 | USA | 146 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Not used | PROM | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
84 | Liang | 1986 | Sep 1983–Mar 1984 | Hong Kong | 168 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Not used | All | WPR | 1 | 51,490 |
22 | Persson | 1986 | Sep 1983–Oct 1984 | Sweden | 1,786 | Nested case-control | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | All | EUR | 2 | 50,110 |
76 | Bobitt | 1985 | n/a | USA | 937 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
40 | Broekhuizen | 1985 | Jul 1981–Dec 1983 | USA | 53 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Unknown | PPROM | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
50 | McGrady | 1985 | 1980–1981 | USA | 1,342 | Cohort | Multi-center | Mixed | >7 days | Unknown | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
83 | Visconti | 1985 | Apr 1980–Jan 1983 | Italy | 1,516 | Cohort | Multi-center | Urban | >7 days | Unknown | All | EUR | 2 | 35,150 |
82 | Weintraub | 1983 | n/a | Israel | 385 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | EUR | 2 | 27,170 |
68 | Christensen | 1982 | Nov 1979–Jun 1980 | Sweden | 300 | Cohort | Health facility | Unknown | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | EUR | 2 | 50,110 |
39 | Pass | 1982 | Jul 1977–Jun 1980 | USA | 68 | Cohort | Multi-center | Urban | >7 days | Used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
58 | Wilson | 1982 | Sep 1978–Aug 1980 | USA | 143 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Used | PPROM | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
67 | Boyer | 1981 | Sep 1977–Apr 1979 | USA | 924 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Not used | Preterm or PROM | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
81 | Merenstein | 1980 | n/a | USA | 1,815 | Cohort | Unknown | Unknown | ≤7 days | Not used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
103 | Tafari | 1979 | 1975–1978 | Ethiopia | 1,351 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | ≤7 days | Unknown | All | AFR | 36 | 390 |
38 | Bobitt | 1977 | Oct 1974–May 1975 | USA | 12 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Unknown | Preterm or PROM | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
49 | Elder | 1971 | n/a | USA | 9,156 | Cohort | Health facility | Urban | >7 days | Not used | All | AMR | 4 | 47,390 |
WHO regions: AFR: Africa; AMR: Americas; EMR: Eastern Mediterrean; EUR: Europe; SEAR: Southeast Asia; WPR: Western Pacific.