Skip to main content
. 2013 Jul 4;8:164. doi: 10.1186/1748-717X-8-164

Table 7.

Summary of differences between treatment plan and radiobiological parameters from the two algorithms for lung treatment

  Parameters   AAA Mean sd PBC Mean sd p
PTV
 D2%(Gy)
  
 61.4
 0.3
 63.2
 0.3
 <0.001
 
 D95%(Gy)
  
 56.0
 0.4
 57.9
 0.5
 <0.001
 
 Dmean(Gy)
  
 58.7
 0.4
 60.5
 0.3
 <0.001
 
 II(%)
  
 11.0
 0.6
 9.0
 0.6
 <0.001
 
 TCP(%)
  
 78.4
 3.0
 86.7
 1.0
 <0.001
Lung
 D2%(Gy)
  
 55.7
 4.8
 59.3
 5.5
 <0.001
 
 D20%(Gy)
  
 23.4
 9.7
 23.2
 10.9
 0.880
 
 D60%(Gy)
  
 4.1
 3.0
 3.0
 2.5
 <0.001
 
 Dmean(Gy)
  
 17.5
 5.0
 17.1
 5.1
 0.281
 
 V20(%)
  
 26.2
 12.9
 24.5
 13.2
 0.045
 
  
 LKB model
    
  
  
  
 
 NTCP (%)
 Ref.
  
  
  
  
  
 
  
 Emami et al. [39] /Burman et al. [23]
 28.5
 16.3
 33.0
 16.3
 0.040
 
  
 Kwa et al. [60]
 7.0
 4.9
 8.0
 5.9
 0.026
 
  
 Seppenwoolde et al. [38]
 8.9
 5.4
 9.8
 6.1
 <0.001
 
  
 De Jeager et al. [24]†
 10.6
 4.8
 11.4
 5.2
 0.024
 
  
 De Jeager et al. [24]††
 14.9
 7.2
 15.6
 7.0
 0.055
 
  
 Seriality model
    
  
  
  
 
  
 Emami et al. [39] /Ågren-Cronqvist [40]
 23.7
 15.7
 27.6
 15.8
 0.022
 
  
 Seppenwoolde et al. [38]
 7.9
 4.7
 8.8
 5.4
 <0.001
 
  
 Gagliardi et al. [61]*
 18.8
 8.0
 21.3
 8.9
 <0.001
    Gagliardi et al. [61]** 14.4 9.1 15.9 9.9 <0.001

* left lung; ** right lung.

† Tissue inhomogeneity correction: Equivalent-path.

†† Tissue inhomogeneity correction: Convolution-superposition.

Insignificant differences (p > 0.05) are in bold.