Table 3.
Study | Patients | Mechanism of cardioprotection | Therapeutic strategy | Results |
---|---|---|---|---|
Anti-inflammatory agents | ||||
Granger et al. (2003)71 (COMMA) | 960 patients | Pexelizumab is an anti-inflammatory antibody which has been reported to reduce MI size by binding to and inhibiting the C5 component of complement pathway | Intravenous pexelizumab 2 mg/kg bolus only given prior to PPCI. Or bolus followed by 0.05 mg/kg/h infusion for 24 h | No difference in primary endpoint of AUC CK-MB |
All STEMI | However, the 90-d mortality rate was significantly lower with pexelizumab bolus plus infusion (1.8% vs. 5.9% with placebo, p=0.014) | |||
<6 h | Therefore, APEX-MI planned | |||
All TIMI flow | ||||
Collaterals included | ||||
Armstrong et al. (2007)72 (APEX-MI) | 5745 patients | Intravenous pexelizumab 2 mg/kg bolus given over 10 min prior to PPCI followed by 0.05 mg/kg/h infusion for 24 h | No difference in primary endpoint of 30 day death (pexelizumab 4.1% vs. 3.9% placebo) | |
All STEMI | ||||
<6 h | ||||
All TIMI flow | ||||
Collaterals included | ||||
Atar et al. (2009)73 (F.I.R.E.) | 232 patients | FX06 is a cleavage product of fibrin which inhibits inflammation by preventing the activation of endothelial VEcadherin | IV bolus of FX06 (200 mg) immediately prior to guidewire crossing obstruction and then repeated 10 min later | No difference in MI size by CMR at 5 days or 4 months |
All STEMI | Animal studies report MI reduction with FX06 | No difference in MI size by tropinin | ||
<6 h | ||||
All TIMI flow | ||||
Collaterals included | ||||
Adenosine | ||||
Ross et al. (2005)74 (AMISTAD II) | 2118 patients | Adenosine has been reported to protect the heart in experimental studies by activating pro-survival kinases and anti-inflammatory mechanism | Intravenous infusion of adenosine 50 or 70 µg/kg/min for 3 h. Started after PPCI | No difference in primary endpoint of primary end point was new CHF beginning <24 h after randomization, or the first re-hospitalization for CHF, or death from any cause within 6 months |
Ant STEMI | However, whether it was effective at reperfusion was inconclusive | Subsequent post-hoc analysis suggested that in patients presenting within 3.17 h there was a beneficial effect with adenosine | ||
<6 h | Experimental evidence inconclusive | |||
All TIMI flow | ||||
Collaterals included | ||||
Glucose insulin potassium (GIK) therapy | ||||
Mehta et al. (2005)75 (CREATE-ECLA) | 20,201 patients | GIK therapy reported in experimental studies to limit MI size via the activation of pro-survival kinases | IV infusion of GIK (25% glucose, 50U/l insulin, 80 mEq/lof potassium to be infused at a rate of 1.5 ml/kg/h) for 24 h. Started after reperfusion in majority of patients | No difference in 30 d mortality (9.7% placebo vs. 10.0% GIK) |
All STEMI | Initial promising clinical studies | Majority of patients treated by thrombolysis and not PPCI | ||
Most patients received thrombolysis | GIK administered prior to reperfusion in only 1437 patients | |||
<12 h | ||||
All TIMI flow | ||||
Collaterals included | ||||
Nicorandil | ||||
Kitakaze et al. (2007)34 (J-WIND) | 545 patients | Nicorandil is an anti-anginal which is also known to limit MI size via the activation of the mitochondrial KATP channel and the release of nitric oxide, both of which are known mediators of IPost | IV bolus of nicorandil (0.067 mg/kg) followed by infusion at 1.67 µg/kg/min for 72 h. Started after PPCI | No difference in MI size or LVEF |
All STEMI | Nicorandil was given after PPCI | |||
<12 h | Inconclusive whether nicorandil administered at reperfusion was protective in experimental studies | |||
All TIMI flow | ||||
Collaterals included | ||||
Erythropoietin | ||||
Ferriario et al. (2009)76 | 30 patients | EPO is a haemopoietic cytokine which is also known to limit MI size at reperfusion via the intracellular activation of the RISK pathway (a known mediator of IPost) | IV EPO 33,000 iU prior to PPCI repeated 24 and 48 h later | 30% reduction in 120 h AUC CK-MB but no difference in MI size using CMR at 3 days and 6 months |
All STEMI | Large animal studies inconclusive | |||
<6 h | ||||
All TIMI flow | ||||
Collaterals included | ||||
Suh et al. (2010)77 | 57 patients | IV EPO 50 iU/kg prior to PPCI | No beneficial effects on MI size (assessed by 72 h AUC CK-MB and CMR at 4 days) | |
Ant STEMI | ||||
<12 h | ||||
TIMI 0 flow | ||||
Collaterals included | ||||
Ozawa et al. (2010)78 (EPO-AMI-1) | 36 patients | IV EPO epoetin-beta 12,000 iU after (within 24 h) PPCI | Increase in LVEF at 6 months | |
STEMI | ||||
<24 h | ||||
All TIMI flow | ||||
Collaterals included | ||||
Voors et al. (2010)79 (HEBE-III) | 529 patient | IV EPO epoetin-alpha 60,000 iU after (within 3 h) PPCI | No difference in primary endpoint of LVEF at 6 weeks | |
STEMI | No difference in MI size (AUC CK-MB or tropinin T) | |||
<12 h | More major adverse cardiac events occurred with EPO | |||
All TIMI flow | ||||
Collaterals included | ||||
Tanaguichi et al. (2010)80 (EPOC-AMI) | 35 patients | IV EPO epoetin-alpha 6000 iU after (within 3 h) PPCI repeated 24 and 48 h later | Improvement in LVEF and smaller MI size at 4 days and 6 months by SPECT | |
STEMI | ||||
<12 h | ||||
All TIMI flow | ||||
Collaterals included | ||||
Ott et al. (2010)81 (REVIVAL-3) | 138 patients | IV EPO epoetin-beta 33,000 iU immediately after PPCI repeated 24 and 48 h later | No difference in LVEF at 6 months assessed by CMR (primary endpoint) | |
STEMI | No difference in MI size (5 days and 6 month CMR) | |||
<12 h | ||||
All TIMI flow | ||||
Collaterals included | ||||
Ludman et al. (2011)82 | 52 patients | IV EPO epoetin-beta 50,000 iU prior to PPCI repeated 24 h later | No difference in MI size at 3 days using CMR and troponin T | |
All STEMI | Doubling of incidence of MVO on CMR | |||
<12 h | ||||
All TIMI flow | ||||
No collaterals | ||||
Rao et al. (2011) (REVEAL, unpublished) | 138 patients | IV EPO epoetin-beta 60,000 iU immediately after PPCI repeated 24 and 48 h later | No difference in MI size on CMR within 6 days and 3 months | |
STEMI | Trend to increased adverse events in patients over 70 years old | |||
<8 h | ||||
All TIMI flow | ||||
Collaterals included | ||||
Protein kinase C-δ inhibitor | ||||
Bates et al. (2008)83 (DELTA-MI) | 154 patients | A drug which is known to limit MI size by inhibiting the pro-apoptotic protein kinase, PKC-δ. This mechanism also contributes to IPost | Intracoronary KAI-9803 (delcasertib) at different doses (0.05, 0.5, 1.25 and 5.0 mg) administered in two divided doses prior to and after PPCI | Safe, efficacy not primary endpoint but non-significant reductions in MI size by CK-MB and SPECT |
Ant STEMI | ||||
<6 h | ||||
All TIMI flow | ||||
No collaterals | ||||
Lincoff et al. (2011) (PROTECTION-AMI, unpublished) | 1083 patients | Intravenous KAI-9803 (delcasertib) at different doses 50, 150, and 450 mg/h) for 24 h started prior to PPCI | No difference on primary endpoint of infarct size as assessed by CK-MB AUC | |
Ant/Inf STEMI | Takes 5–30 min to reach steady state after infusion begun | |||
<6 h | ||||
All TIMI flow | ||||
No collaterals | ||||
Atorvastatin | ||||
Kim et al. (2010)84 STATIN STEMI | 171 patients | A variety of pleiotropic effects including MI size reduction via the direct intracellular activation of the RISK pathway (a known mediator of IPost) | Atorvastatin 80 mg versus atorvastatin 10 mg prior to PPCI | No effect on primary endpoint of (death, MI, revasc) |
STEMI | No difference in MI size (CKMB max) | |||
<12 h | Improved myocardial perfusion (blush grade, STR) | |||
All TIMI flow | ||||
No collaterals |
AUC, area under the curve; CHF, congestive heart failure; CK, creatine kinase; CMR, cardiac MRI; EPO, erythropoietin; IPost, ischaemic postconditioning; LVEF, left ventricular ejection fraction; MI, myocardial infarct; MVO, microvascular obstruction; PPCI, primary percutaneous coronary intervention; SPECT, single photon emission CT; STEMI, ST-segment elevation MI; STR, ST-segment resolution; TIMI, thrombolysis in myocardial infarction.