Appendix 2.
Summary of ordering of vignettes for mobility (N=9,375) and cognition (N=8,788) domain. Vignettes 1–5 ordered by increasing level of severity. Upper triangle = p i<j−p j<i. Lower triangle = 1 − p i < j−p j < i, where p i<j is the proportion of respondents rating vignette i < vignette j and p j<i is the proportion rating vignette j < vignette i. Negative values in upper triangle of matrix suggest mis-ordering of corresponding vignette pair (in boldface). Large values in lower triangle suggest high proportion of tied ratings for corresponding vignette pair.
| Navrongo, Ghana | Mobility – moving around | Mobility – vigorous activity | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .57 | .91 | .93 | .93 | NA | .81 | .95 | .94 | .93 |
| Vig_2 | .34 | NA | .71 | .87 | .93 | .13 | NA | .71 | .78 | .89 |
| Vig_3 | .04 | .09 | NA | .28 | .80 | .03 | .19 | NA | .11 | .55 |
| Vig_4 | .15 | .48 | .02 | NA | .69 | .21 | .59 | .05 | NA | .50 |
| Vig_5 | .02 | .02 | .12 | .19 | NA | .02 | .02 | .34 | .37 | NA |
| Cognition – memory | Cognition – learning | |||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .49 | .88 | .95 | .97 | NA | .57 | .93 | .96 | .98 |
| Vig_2 | .40 | NA | .62 | .83 | .95 | .38 | NA | .69 | .84 | .95 |
| Vig_3 | .11 | .11 | NA | .40 | .91 | .05 | .11 | NA | .31 | .91 |
| Vig_4 | .21 | .32 | .03 | NA | .86 | .23 | .38 | .03 | NA | .83 |
| Vig_5 | .03 | .01 | .05 | .10 | NA | .04 | .01 | .05 | .13 | NA |
| Nairobi, Kenya | Mobility – moving around | Mobility – vigorous activity | ||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .45 | .80 | .95 | .92 | NA | .88 | .92 | .94 | .91 |
| Vig_2 | .45 | NA | .56 | .89 | .91 | .08 | NA | .16 | .39 | .63 |
| Vig_3 | .16 | .08 | NA | .57 | .82 | .04 | .43 | NA | .28 | .48 |
| Vig_4 | .27 | .32 | .01 | NA | .64 | .31 | .46 | .24 | NA | .30 |
| Vig_5 | .02 | .03 | .10 | .25 | NA | .03 | .05 | .34 | .53 | NA |
| Cognition – memory | Cognition – learning | |||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .54 | .90 | .88 | .96 | NA | .23 | .85 | .72 | .94 |
| Vig_2 | .33 | NA | .66 | .70 | .95 | .57 | NA | .74 | .57 | .89 |
| Vig_3 | .05 | .20 | NA | .18 | .73 | .04 | .19 | NA | −.11 | .68 |
| Vig_4 | .22 | .26 | .03 | NA | .60 | .11 | .34 | .70 | NA | .71 |
| Vig_5 | .04 | .02 | .25 | .30 | NA | .21 | .02 | .25 | .22 | NA |
| Agincourt, South Africa | Mobility – moving around | Mobility – vigorous activity | ||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .40 | .74 | .81 | .81 | NA | .47 | .80 | .84 | .84 |
| Vig_2 | .49 | NA | .61 | .70 | .80 | .38 | NA | .63 | .69 | .79 |
| Vig_3 | .09 | .13 | NA | .12 | .52 | .09 | .20 | NA | .14 | .51 |
| Vig_4 | .15 | .50 | .07 | NA | .53 | .15 | .50 | .08 | NA | .47 |
| Vig_5 | .10 | .08 | .32 | .29 | NA | .09 | .07 | .29 | .38 | NA |
| Cognition – memory | Cognition – learning | |||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .48 | .63 | .55 | .70 | NA | .40 | .56 | .51 | .64 |
| Vig_2 | .29 | NA | .41 | .47 | .71 | .27 | NA | .25 | .45 | .61 |
| Vig_3 | .19 | .22 | NA | .20 | .60 | .15 | .23 | NA | .29 | .53 |
| Vig_4 | .23 | .42 | .15 | NA | .62 | .28 | .32 | .19 | NA | .47 |
| Vig_5 | .15 | .13 | .19 | .20 | NA | .16 | .12 | .23 | .21 | NA |
| Ifakara, Tanzania | Mobility – moving around | Mobility – vigorous activity | ||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .49 | .80 | .89 | .93 | NA | .65 | .84 | .87 | .92 |
| Vig_2 | .38 | NA | .53 | .71 | .89 | .21 | NA | .45 | .56 | .83 |
| Vig_3 | .14 | .18 | NA | .23 | .70 | .09 | .28 | NA | .10 | .62 |
| Vig_4 | .28 | .41 | .06 | NA | .57 | .30 | .49 | .10 | NA | .54 |
| Vig_5 | .05 | .03 | .20 | .32 | NA | .06 | .04 | .26 | .34 | NA |
| Cognition – memory | Cognition – learning | |||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .37 | .50 | .59 | .63 | NA | .33 | .50 | .57 | .63 |
| Vig_2 | .37 | NA | .22 | .41 | .52 | .38 | NA | .26 | .38 | .49 |
| Vig_3 | .27 | .28 | NA | .26 | .45 | .27 | .27 | NA | .21 | .40 |
| Vig_4 | .39 | .33 | .12 | NA | .30 | .36 | .38 | .15 | NA | .29 |
| Vig_5 | .23 | .18 | .14 | .31 | NA | .23 | .18 | .16 | .32 | NA |
| Matlab, Bangladesh | Mobility – moving around | Mobility – vigorous activity | ||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .60 | .90 | .96 | .98 | NA | .87 | .93 | .96 | .97 |
| Vig_2 | .34 | NA | .45 | .76 | .89 | .09 | NA | .30 | .52 | .66 |
| Vig_3 | .07 | .15 | NA | .52 | .79 | .03 | .32 | NA | .23 | .41 |
| Vig_4 | .31 | .32 | .08 | NA | .38 | .39 | .54 | .28 | NA | .19 |
| Vig_5 | .02 | .01 | .18 | .47 | NA | .02 | .01 | .52 | .70 | NA |
| Cognition – memory | Cognition – learning | |||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .66 | .95 | .97 | .97 | NA | .44 | .91 | .93 | .96 |
| Vig_2 | .28 | NA | .71 | .89 | .94 | .46 | NA | .74 | .85 | .92 |
| Vig_3 | .02 | .08 | NA | .39 | .58 | .06 | .10 | NA | .23 | .50 |
| Vig_4 | .19 | .36 | .03 | NA | .28 | .18 | .38 | .05 | NA | .32 |
| Vig_5 | .02 | .02 | .29 | .52 | NA | .04 | .02 | .32 | .46 | NA |
| Vadu, India | Mobility – moving around | Mobility – vigorous activity | ||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .44 | .67 | .73 | .78 | NA | .51 | .68 | .71 | .72 |
| Vig_2 | .27 | NA | .42 | .69 | .77 | .31 | NA | .33 | .53 | .62 |
| Vig_3 | .17 | .19 | NA | .38 | .67 | .15 | .21 | NA | .31 | .54 |
| Vig_4 | .32 | .33 | .10 | NA | .58 | .29 | .33 | .14 | NA | .44 |
| Vig_5 | .12 | .10 | .18 | .20 | NA | .12 | .11 | .22 | .28 | NA |
| Cognition – memory | Cognition – learning | |||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .28 | .67 | .75 | .65 | NA | .28 | .72 | .72 | .65 |
| Vig_2 | .42 | NA | .58 | .65 | .55 | .44 | NA | .63 | .63 | .56 |
| Vig_3 | .12 | .18 | NA | .20 | .08 | .13 | .17 | NA | .10 | .06 |
| Vig_4 | .21 | .56 | .16 | NA | −.11 | .19 | .48 | .20 | NA | −.08 |
| Vig_5 | .15 | .18 | .53 | .53 | NA | .14 | .17 | .49 | .54 | NA |
| Purworejo, Indonesia | Mobility – moving around | Mobility – vigorous activity | ||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .47 | .69 | .86 | .95 | NA | .66 | .81 | .91 | .95 |
| Vig_2 | .39 | NA | .38 | .72 | .92 | .22 | NA | .40 | .70 | .88 |
| Vig_3 | .22 | .20 | NA | .45 | .84 | .11 | .22 | NA | .39 | .76 |
| Vig_4 | .38 | .36 | .05 | NA | .65 | .35 | .42 | .08 | NA | .56 |
| Vig_5 | .09 | .02 | .12 | .29 | NA | .04 | .02 | .19 | .36 | NA |
| Cognition – memory | Cognition – learning | |||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .45 | .80 | .90 | .94 | NA | .37 | .83 | .89 | .93 |
| Vig_2 | .44 | NA | .53 | .78 | .89 | .50 | NA | .62 | .79 | .89 |
| Vig_3 | .12 | .14 | NA | .47 | .75 | .10 | .13 | NA | .43 | .72 |
| Vig_4 | .29 | .34 | .07 | NA | .45 | .22 | .37 | .07 | NA | .43 |
| Vig_5 | .06 | .03 | .18 | .41 | NA | .06 | .04 | .21 | .43 | NA |
| Filabavi, Vietnam | Mobility – moving around | Mobility – vigorous activity | ||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .40 | .82 | .96 | .98 | NA | .88 | .94 | .96 | .97 |
| Vig_2 | .55 | NA | .59 | .84 | .96 | .08 | NA | .51 | .65 | .83 |
| Vig_3 | .14 | .10 | NA | .45 | .89 | .03 | .29 | NA | .17 | .51 |
| Vig_4 | .25 | .41 | .02 | NA | .77 | .35 | .61 | .15 | NA | .36 |
| Vig_5 | .02 | .00 | .10 | .20 | NA | .02 | .01 | .45 | .59 | NA |
| Cognition – memory | Cognition – learning | |||||||||
| Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | Vig_1 | Vig_2 | Vig_3 | Vig_4 | Vig_5 | |
| Vig_1 | NA | .54 | .90 | .94 | .94 | NA | .43 | .93 | .93 | .95 |
| Vig_2 | .39 | NA | .71 | .88 | .91 | .48 | NA | .79 | .88 | .92 |
| Vig_3 | .06 | .08 | NA | .46 | .67 | .03 | .07 | NA | .41 | .65 |
| Vig_4 | .18 | .40 | .05 | NA | .34 | .13 | .40 | .04 | NA | .33 |
| Vig_5 | .02 | .02 | .26 | .51 | NA | .03 | .02 | .27 | .53 | NA |