Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Jul 3.
Published in final edited form as: J Am Chem Soc. 2013 Jun 19;135(26):9785–9796. doi: 10.1021/ja402525c

Table 4.

Single point energies (kcal/mol) for QMopt structures (with no further relaxation) obtained using different methods.

Method/stem AA SA-
aabb
SA-
abab
SA-
abab2
SA-
aaab
3AA+1SS AS SA-aaaa
PBa 0 −24.6 −10.0 −37.2 −22.5 −0.4 +1.7 −57.8
GB 0 −16.0 −3.2 −28.3 −15.1 +5.1 +6.2 −37.7
QMb 0 +0.4 +9.8 −4.4 +3.9 +6.8 +16.7 −21.5
gas phase QM 0 +27.3 +26.1 +23.1 +30.8 +12.2 +44.6 −7.6
gas phase force field 0 +12.8 +16.6 +2.9 +17.7 +10.6 +53.6 −38.2
a

The PB data in this Table marginally differ from the Table 1 QM→MMopt data since additional PB relaxation has been done in the Table 1. Note that the purpose of computations in Tables 1 and 4 was slightly different. The Table 1 QM→ MMopt calculations were done to obtain MM structures and energies using the QMopt geometry as the start, while the purpose of Table 4 was to derive energies by all methods on entirely unprocessed QMopt structures.

b

The reference QMopt data from the Table 1.