Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Jul 27.
Published in final edited form as: J Comput Aided Mol Des. 2013 Jul 27;27(7):569–582. doi: 10.1007/s10822-013-9662-6

Table 4.

Comparison of AutoDock-Vina poses of O2N-[HoPhe]-Ala-COOH obtained by XPLOR-NIH minimization with PRE-derived distance constraints *

2R5D Ligand fixeda Ligand allowed to moveb

pose RMSD PRE / s−1 PRE Q factor RMSD Dist. / Å c Ligand positional RMSD d RMSD PRE / s−1 PRE Q factor RMSD Dist. / Å c Ligand positional RMSD d

1 11.78 0.27 1.174 0.379 2.63 0.058 0.139 1.01

2 11.91 0.26 1.414 0.424 3.44 0.077 0.151 1.764
3 27.23 0.61 4.431 0.506 16.51 0.37 2.198 3.899
4 23.16 0.52 3.558 0.956 12.65 0.28 1.428 2.31
5 21.44 0.48 3.259 1.434 17.38 0.39 2.545 1.315

6 12.36 0.28 0.843 0.408 3.31 0.043 0.102 1.798

7 16.11 0.36 1.535 1.181 1.93 0.020 0.036 2.351
8 24.75 0.56 3.924 0.745 22.32 0.50 2.969 2.491

9 19.06 0.42 3.06 0.837 1.73 0.035 0.073 1.923

3P7K Fixeda Movedb

1 20.57 0.46 2.714 0.301 3.47 0.056 0.139 1.657

2 10.41 0.23 1.209 0.565 3.07 0.068 0.181 1.855
3 17.98 0.41 2.235 1.435 11.91 0.27 1.706 1.415

4 10.53 0.24 0.817 0.49 4.49 0.042 0.116 0.946
5 21.26 0.48 2.324 1.278 13.80 0.31 1.253 2.737
6 28.84 0.65 4.515 1.718 26.91 0.61 4.301 1.71
7 16.75 0.38 2.266 0.628 16.47 0.37 2.117 0.84
8 25.49 0.57 3.77 2.033 12.81 0.29 1.282 2.702
9 20.96 0.47 2.914 0.699 18.74 0.42 2.418 0.626
*

Experimental error range included in calculation of RMSD and Q factors; low values are shaded in gray; PRE Q factor measures the agreement between observed and calculated PRE according to the equation [Σi = [PREobs(i)- PREcalc(i)]2/[Σ iPREobs(i)2]½.

a

XPLOR-optimized ligand position fixed during PRE-derived distance - constrained minimization, protein side chains and MTSL allowed to move;

b

Ligand allowed to move during PRE-derived distance - constrained minimization, weak harmonic constraints (scaling factor 0.2 – 0.8) applied to protein side chains, MTSL side chain unconstrained;

c

PRE-derived distances calculated at τc=12ns;

d

Compared to original docked structure, all heavy atom RMSD, in Å