Skip to main content
. 2013 Aug 21;98(4):1084–1102. doi: 10.3945/ajcn.113.058362

TABLE 1.

Characteristics of studies included in meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies in children1

Reference Study population and location Sample size Mean ± SD baseline age or age range Duration Dietary assessment method Outcome assessment method Study question Covariates Adjusted for energy
Ludwig, 2001 (16) Intervention and Evaluation Project, Planet Health, Massachusetts 548 11.7 ± 0.8 y 19 mo FFQ BMI based on measured height and weight Change in SSBs from baseline to end of follow-up and BMI at end of follow-up Baseline BMI, age, sex, ethnicity, school, percentage of energy from fat and energy-adjusted fruit juice intake at baseline and change from baseline to follow-up, physical activity, television, and change in television from baseline to follow-up No
Berkey, 2004 (17) Growing Up Today Study (GUTs), 50 states, USA 11,703 9–14 y 2 y 132-item FFQ Self-reported BMI 1-y change in SSB intake and change in BMI Age, Tanner stage, race, menarche (girls), prior BMI z score, height growth, milk type, physical activity, inactivity, diet soda juice, milk No
Newby, 2004 (8) North Dakota, Women, Infants, and Children (WIC), USA 1345 2–5 y 6–12 mo 84-item FFQ BMI based on measured height and weight SSB intake at baseline and change in BMI between baseline and end of follow-up Age, sex, total energy, ethnicity, residence, level of poverty, maternal education, and birth weight Yes
Blum, 2005 (7) Nebraska schoolchildren, USA 166 9.3 ± 1.0 y 2 y 24-h diet recall BMI z score based on measured height and weight SSB intake and year 2 BMI z score Baseline BMI z score, age, sex, age × sex, baseline and year 2 milk, juice, diet soda, SSBs, total calories Yes
Mundt, 2006 (9) University of Saskatchewan's Pediatric Bone Mineral Accrual Study, Canada 208 8–15 y 7 y 24-h diet recall Fat mass (kg) using dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry SSB intake at each measurement occasion and change in fat mass (kg) over time Age, fat-free mass, physical activity, adjusted total energy adjusted for SSBs Yes, but SSBs removed from total energy
Striegal-Moore,2006 (10) National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute Growth and Health Study, California, Ohio, Maryland, USA 2379 girls 9–10 y 10 y 3-d diet records BMI based on measured height and weight SSB intake at each measurement occasion and change in BMI over time Milk, diet soda, fruit juice, fruit drinks, coffee/tea, site, visit (proxy for age), race, and total energy Yes
Viner, 2006 (18) 1970 British cohort, UK 4461 16 y 14 y Questionnaire, intake the day before BMI z score based on measured height and weight at baseline and self-reported at end of follow-up SSB at baseline and BMI z score at the end of follow-up Baseline BMI z score, sex, SES, and height at baseline and end of follow-up No
Johnson, 2007 (11) Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children, UK 682 5 y 4 y Parent-administered 3-d unweighed diet records Fat mass (kg) using dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry SSB intake at age 5 y and fat mass (kg) at age 9 y Sex, height at 9 y, BMI at baseline, television, maternal education, paternal class, maternal BMI, paternal BMI, misreporting of energy intake, dietary energy density, percentage of energy from fat, and fiber density No
Laurson, 2008 (15) Idaho, Montana, Wyoming, rural USA 268 10 y 18 mo Diet and lifestyle questionnaire BMI based on measured height and weight Change in SSB intake and change in BMI from baseline to end of follow-up Age, baseline BMI, change in height, ethnicity, and state of residence No
Libuda, 2008 (12) DONALD study, Germany 244 Girls: 11.8 ± 1.5 y; boys: 11.9 ± 1.6 y 5 y Self- and parent-administered 3-d weighed diet records BMI-SDS based on measured height and weight 1-y change in SSB intake and change in BMI-SDS Time and age No
Vanselow, 2009 (19) Project EAT (Eating Among Teens) II Minnesota, USA 2294 14.9 y 5 y 149-item FFQ Self-reported BMI SSBs at end of follow-up and change in BMI from baseline to end of follow-up Age, sex, race, SES, baseline BMI, baseline SSBs No
Carlson, 2012 (21) Control group of a community-based obesity-prevention program California, USA 254 6.7 ± 0.7 y 2 y Parent-administered diet and lifestyle questionnaire BMI z score based on measured height and weight Change in SSB intake and change in BMI z score from baseline to end of follow-up Age, sex, ethnicity, parent education, height No
Laska, 2012 (14) Identifying Determinants of Eating and Activity (IDEA) and the Etiology of Childhood Obesity (ECHO) studies, Minnesota, USA 693 14.6 y 2 y 24-h diet recall BMI based on measured height and weight Change in SSB intake and change in BMI from baseline to end of follow-up Physical activity, puberty, race, parental education, eligibility for free/reduced-price lunch, age, and study No
Olsen, 2012 (13) European Youth Heart Study, Denmark 359 9.6 y 6 y 24-h diet recall, supplemented with FFQ, diet record BMI z score based on measured height and weight SSB intake at baseline and change in BMI z score between baseline and follow-up Baseline anthropometric measures, total intake of complex carbohydrates, total intake of fat, maternal SES, maternal SES × sex, started puberty, physical activity, sex, intake of solid sucrose No
1

DONALD, DOrtmund Nutritional and Anthropometric Longitudinally Designed; FFQ, food-frequency questionnaire; SDS, SD score; SES, socioeconomic status; SSB, sugar-sweetened beverage.