Table 1.
SC types | Delivery route (injection into) | Patient number | Main patient characteristics | Outcome (patient number) | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Olfactory ensheathing cells | Pathological regions of the spinal cord and/or bilateral corona radiata of the brain | 327 | ➢ Onset spinal ➢Age 20–84 ➢Months from onset 4, 8–156 |
Safe and well tolerated (short term (4 weeks)) Few side effects (16) Improvement rate of neurological function (252) |
139 |
Olfactory ensheathing cells | Frontal lobe | 1 | ➢ Onset spinal ➢ Age 20–84 ➢ Months from onset 4, 8–156 |
Faster disease rate Disabling side-effects |
142 |
Autologous Bone marrow mesenchymal SCs | Laminectomy + mielotomy Central part of thoracic spinal cord | 9 | ➢ Onset spinal ➢ Age 32–75 ➢ Months from diagnosis 8–60 |
Safe and well tolerated in the long term (4 years follow-up) | 71–75 |
Peripheral blood SCs | Mobilization with GCSF treatment | 8 | ➢ Onset limb (7 patients) ➢ Age nr ➢ Months from onset 3–48 |
Safe and well tolerated No significant changes in disease progression |
135 |
Mobilized allogenic hematopoietic SCs | Total body irradiation Intravenous infusion Immuno-suppression |
6 | ➢ Onset spinal or bulbar ➢ Age 35–59 ➢ Months from diagnosis 5–30 |
Tolerated with some immunological problems (3) No clinical benefits immune cells in spinal cord (3 autopsies) |
112 |
Fetal olfactory ensheathing cells | Bilateral corona radiata involving the pyramidal tracts of the frontal lobes | 15 | ➢ Onset nr ➢ Age nr ➢ Months from diagnosis/onset nr |
Safe and well tolerated (short term (4 months) No significant difference in the rate of progression (first 2 months) Significant difference in functional deterioration (last 2 months) (7) |
140 |
Autologous Bone marrow hematopoietic progenitors | Laminectomy Anterior part of spinal cord (C1-C2) | 13 | ➢ Onset nr ➢ Age 34–71 ➢ Months from diagnosis 8–60 |
Clinical benefits (9) (1 year follow-up) No clinical benefits (1) (1 year follow-up) |
125 |
Autologous blood purified CD133+ cells | Bilateral implantation in frontal motor cortex with stereotaxy or neuronavigation guidance | 10 | ➢ Onset spinal ➢ Age 38–62 ➢ Months from diagnosis 18–42 |
Safe and well tolerated (1 year follow-up) Significant changes in disease progression vs control group |
124 |
Fetal olfactory ensheathing cells | Bilateral corona radiata involving the pyramidal tracts of the frontal lobes | 457 | ➢ Onset nr ➢ Age nr ➢ Months from diagnosis nr |
Improvement of the patients’ neurological functions and/or decrease the progressive deterioration | 141 |
Autologous Bone marrow SCs | Laminectomy Posterior part of spinal cord | 11 | ➢ Onset medullar ➢ Age 33–61 ➢ Months from diagnosis nr |
Safe and well tolerated in the short term (some months) Transient hematoma 7 days after surgery(MRI) Grafted cells in spinal cord (2 autopsies) |
143 |
Autologous Bone marrow SCs | Spinal tap | nr | nr | Ongoing patient enrolment | Press release: http://www.tcacellulartherapy.com/pdf/forbes als-0110.pdf |
Neural SCs | Lumbar area of spinal cord | 12 | Phase i trial ongoing 4 patient surgeries done (3 patients with unilateral injections, 1 patient bilateral injections into the spinal cord) | Estimated 24 months follow-up Ongoing patient enrolment Tolerated (short time) |
http://www2.med.umich.edu/prmc/media/newsroom/details.cfm?ID=1306 |
Abbreviation: nr, not reported.