Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2014 Nov 1.
Published in final edited form as: Crit Rev Oncol Hematol. 2013 Jun 16;88(2):437–446. doi: 10.1016/j.critrevonc.2013.05.001

Table 1.

Summary of the various methods used to define, measure, quantify, and manage lymphedema following treatment for breast cancer, as well as the appropriate timing of assessment.

Topic Details References
Definition Circumferential Difference 1.0 – 3.0 cm Tsai 2009 [46], Wernicke 2011 [48]
Volume Difference 200 ml Boccardo 2009 [16], Tsai 2009 [46]
Percent Difference 3 – 20% Armer 2009 [7], Tsai 2009 [46], Stout Gergich 2008 [49]
Self-Report Armer 2010 [6], Norman 2009 [62]
Measurement Tape Measurement Arm circumference Deltombe 2007 [10], Jain 2010 [53]
Water Displacement Volume Deltombe 2007 [10], Tewari 2008 [54], Smoot 2011 [55], Fu 2009 [56], Ridner 2007 [57]
Bioimpedance Spectroscopy Impedance value Smoot 2011 [55], Ward 2011 [58], Ridner 2009 [59]
Perometry Volume Jain 2010 [53], Stanton 1997 [60], Petlund 1991 [61]
Self-Report McLaughlin 2008 [4], Norman 2009 [62], Czerniec 2010 [63]
Quantification Absolute Volume Difference ml or cm difference McLaughlin 2008 [4], Ashikaga 2010 [5], Tsai 2009 [46], Wernicke 2011 [48]
Relative Volume Difference Percent difference between arms Ancukiewicz 2012 [64]
Relative Volume Change (RVC) Percent change between arms as compared to baseline Ancukiewicz 2012 [64], Ancukiewicz 2011 [65]
Timing Pre-operative Arm Volume Measurements Accounts for any normal asymmetry between arms Armer 2010 [6], Stout Gergich 2008 [49], Ancukiewicz 2011 [65], Harris 2001 [66], NLN Position Paper 2011 [67]
Continuous Post-operative Screening Prospective surveillance may allow for early detection and treatment, but has not been fully evaluated for its application, cost and outcome NLN Position Paper 2012 [79], Cheville 2012 [80], Stout 2011 [81]
Management Complex Decongestive Therapy (CDT) Recommended and considered effective; lacks Level 1 evidence to support its use; further study needed to determine efficacy as stand-alone treatment Vignes 2011 [70], Forner-Cordero 2009 [71], Lasinski 2012 [72]
Manual Lymphatic Drainage No signficant impact on edema development when compared to exercise and precautionary advice Devoogdt 2011 [73]
Compression Sleeve without CDT Assessed in a small cohort study without randomization; further study needed Stout Gergich 2008 [49], Partsch 2010 [74]
Pneumatic Compression No robust evidence about long-term outcomes Fife 2012 [75], Wilburn 2006 [76]
Low-Level Laser Treatment Lacks data to support its use Omar 2012 [77]