Table 3.
Author | Year | Time to Partial Weight-bearing | Time to Full Weight-bearing | Brace use | Years to follow-up Mean (Range) | Radiographs Obtained | Radiographic Classification System Utilized |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Salmon | 2006 | 24 Hours | 4 weeks | 30–90 for 4 weeks | 13 | Stand AP Stand 30 PA Lateral Merchant |
IKDC System Grade B,C or D |
Seon | 2006 | 24 Hours | 8 weeks | 30–90 for 8 weeks | 11.2 (8.6–14) | Stand AP Lateral |
Kellgren and Lawrence Grade ≥ 2 |
Hart | 2005 | NR | NR | NR | 10 (9–13) | Stand AP Lateral Merchant |
Ahlback Grade ≥1 |
Hertel | 2005 | NR | NR | NR | 10.7 (9.2–12) | Stand AP | IKDC System Grade B,C, or D |
Giron | 2005 | Immediate | 3–5 weeks | None | 5 | Stand AP Lateral Merchant Notch |
IKDC System Grade B,C, or D |
Wang | 2004 | Immediate | 4–6 weeks if meniscus repaired Immediatein others | 0–90 for 4–6 weeks if meniscus repaired None in others |
5.8 (3.8–7.2) | Stand AP Merchant |
Ahlback Grade ≥1 |
Wu | 2002 | 24 Hours | 24 Hours | 0–90 for 4 weeks if meniscus repaired Hinged brace with full ROM for 4 weeks in others |
10.5 (9–13) | Stand PA Lateral |
Fairbank Grade ≥1 |
Patel | 2000 | NR | NR | NR | 5.9 (5–8.5) | NR | Fairbank Grade ≥1 |
Shelbourne | 2000 | NR | NR | NR | 7.6 (5–15) | Stand 45 PA Lateral Merchant |
IKDC System Grade B,C, or D |
Aglietti | 1997 | 3 weeks | 8 weeks | 10–90 for 4–6 weeks | 7 (5.2–8.7) | Stand AP Lateral Merchant |
IKDC System Grade C or D |
Aglietti | 1994 | NR | NR | NR | 4.5 (3–7.5) | Stand AP Stand 45 PA Lateral Merchant |
HSS Evaluation Score < 26 |
AP – Antero-posterior
PA – Postero-anterior
NR – Not Reported