Skip to main content
. 2013 Oct 8;8(10):e76787. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0076787

Table 2. The quality assessment of included studies.

Newcastle-Ottawa Scale*
Author 1 2 3 4 5A 5B 6 7 8 Total
Ho [22] Yes Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes 7
Montavon [16] Yes Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes 7
Bhagat [23] Yes Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes 7
He [24] Yes Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes 7
Chen [17] Yes Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes 7
Shen [25] Yes Yes No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes 6
Wu [18] Yes Yes No Yes No No Yes Yes Yes 5
Li [26] Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes 8
Makarla [27] Yes Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes 7
Ma [19] Yes No No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes 5
Ibanez [20] Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes 8
Rathi [28] Yes Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes 7
Yoon [21] Yes Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes 7
*

1 indicates case definition and diagnostic appropriate; 2, consecutive patients or case having a good representation; 3, community controls; 4, control with no the history of study disease; 5A, according to the most important factor to select and analyze control; 5B, according to the second important factor to select and analyze control; 6, ascertainment of exposure by blinded interview or record; 7, same method of ascertainment used for cases and controls; and 8, non-response rate the same for cases and controls.