TABLE 4.
Studies that evaluated breakfast and energy intake
First author, year of publication (reference) | Study length | Treatment description | Relevant results | Notes |
Astbury, 2011 (30) | 1-d crossover | Breakfast or no breakfast; plus liquid preload before lunch | No significant differences in total energy intake (breakfast, preload, and ad libitum lunch) | Significant increased ad libitum test meal intake in no-breakfast group |
Geliebter, 1999 (31) | 1-d crossover | 350 kcal oatmeal, sugared cornflakes, or water control | Liquid test meal intake was lower in the oatmeal but not cornflake conditions compared with water control | Overweight M and F subjects |
Geliebter, 1999 (32) | 1-d crossover | 350 kcal oatmeal, sugared cornflakes, or water control | Liquid test meal intake was lower in the oatmeal but not cornflake conditions compared with water control | Lean and overweight M and F subjects; overweight subjects ingested even less after consumption of oatmeal |
Kral, 2011 (33) | 1-d crossover | Breakfast or no breakfast | Significantly higher energy intake in breakfast group | Similar intakes at lunch and rest of day |
Leidy, 2011 (34) | 1-d crossover | No breakfast, normal breakfast, or high-protein breakfast | No significant differences in total energy intake | Protein-rich breakfast lowered lunch intake compared with that with normal and no breakfast |
1) Levitsky, 2013 (35) | 1-d crossover | High carbohydrate, high fiber, or no breakfast; 1.4-MJ breakfasts | Significantly higher energy intake in breakfast groups (breakfast plus lunch) | Similar intakes at lunch |
2) Levitsky, 2013 (35) | 1-d crossover | Ad libitum or no breakfast | Significantly higher daily intake in breakfast group | Significant increase in lunch intake for no-breakfast group |
Taylor, 2001(36) | 2-d crossover | 6 meals/d compared with 4 or 2 meals/d | No significant differences in total energy expenditure or intake | Wide range of BMI above overweight; F only |