Table 3.
First Author | Year | Type of Study (time post-injury) | Magnet | Subjects (N, gender, age) | DTI Analysis Method and Dependent Measures | Brain Region(s) | Main Finding(s) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Arfanakis | 2002 | Acute. (24hrs). In 2 patients, baseline compared with DTI at 1 month follow-up. |
1.5T |
Patients: 5 patients (3M, 2F; mean age 35.6) [GCS 13–15]. Conventional CT normal. Controls: 10 controls (5M, 5F; mean age 28.9 years). |
Analysis and Methods: ROI Analysis. Dependent Measures: Trace, FA and LI. (Lattice Index). |
5 ROI structures with selected volumes (i.e., representative only), in the left and right hemispheres: Anterior and posterior CC, external capsule, anterior and posterior internal capsule. |
|
Inglese | 2005 | Acute and Chronic. In 20 of the patients, imaging was performed at a mean of 4.05 days post- injury. In the remaining 26, imaging was performed a mean of 5.7 years post- injury. |
1.5T |
Patients: 46 patients (29M, 17F; mean age 36) [GCS 13–15]. Conventional MRI showed contusions in 5 patients and hematomas in 3. Controls: 29 age- and sex-matched controls (15 M, 14 F; mean age 35). Negative findings on conventional MRI. |
Analysis and Methods: Whole-Brain Histogram Analysis and ROI Analysis. Dependent Measures: FA and MD. |
3 ROI structures with selected voxels (i.e., representative, only): the centrum semiovale, CC, and internal capsule. |
|
Bazarian | 2007 | Acute. 72 hours: post- concussive (PCS) and neurobehavioral testing. At 1 month: quality of life and PCS assessments (n=11). |
3T |
Patients: 6 subjects [GCS 13–15]. Conventional CT normal. Controls: 6 age- and sex- matched orthopedic controls; Conventional CT normal. Subjects (patients and controls) included 8M and 4F; aged 18–31. |
Analysis and Methods: 2 types of whole brain analyses performed: VBM and a novel, quantile analysis. ROI analysis: Regions of interest were also analyzed using a quantile approach. Dependent Measures: FA, Trace. PCS, neurobehavioral battery, and quality of life assessments. |
|
|
Kraus | 2007 | Chronic. ≥ 6 months out from injury; average 107 months for all TBI subjects. |
3T |
Patients: 37 TBI patients; 20 mTBI (8M, 12F; mean age 35.85) [LOC <30 min], 17 moderate to severe TBI (8M, 9F; mean age 34.88) [LOC >30 min and/or GCS <13]. 5 in each TBI group with other associated trauma. Controls: 18 controls (7M, 11F; mean age 32.83). |
Analysis and Methods: ROI analysis. ROIs drawn on standardized space, FA maps. Dependent Measures: FA, RD, AD, white matter load defined as total number of regions with reduced FA. Neurocognitive measures relevant to attention, memory, and executive function. |
13 ROI structures: anterior and posterior corona radiata, cortico-spinal tracts, cingulum fiber bundles, external capsule, forceps minor and major, genu, body and splenium of the CC, inferior fronto-occipital fasciculus, superior longitudinal fasciculus and sagittal stratum. |
|
Lipton | 2008 | Chronic. 8 months to 3 years Retrospective study of consecutive admissions of mTBI. |
1.5T |
Patients: 17 mTBI patients (8M, 9F; age 26–70) [GCS 13–15, LOC <20 min]. Negative CT/MRI findings at time of initial injury. Later, at time of scanning, 1 mTBI subject had a small area of signal intensity likely due to gliosis. Controls: 10 controls of similar age and gender distribution. Negative MRI findings at time of scan. |
Analysis and Methods: Whole-brain histogram analysis and Voxel- wise analysis of retrospective cases. Dependent Measures: FA, MD. Histogram parameters, i.e., kurtosis, skew. |
Whole-brain analysis. |
|
Miles | 2008 | Acute. Average 4 days (range: 1–10). Follow-up at 6 months for neuropsychological measures. |
1.5T |
Patients: 17 patients (11M, 6F; mean age 33.44, range 18–58) [GCS 13–15, LOC <20 min]. Controls: 29 sex- and age-matched controls (15M, 14F; mean age 35, range 18–61). Not matched on education. |
Analysis and Methods: ROI analysis. Dependent Measures: FA, MD. Neuropsychological measures at baseline (≤24 hour of imaging) and 6 month follow-up for 12/17 mTBI. |
Structural ROI using circles: centra semiovale, the genu and the splenium of the CC, and the posterior limb of the internal capsule. |
|
Niogi | 2008a | Subacute and Chronic. ≥ 1 month (range 1–65 months). ≥ 1 persistent symptom for postconcussive syndrome. |
3T |
Patients: 34 patients (18M, 16F; mean age 37.4, range 16–61). [GCS 13–15]. 11 mTBI- negative MRI findings; 11 mTBI micro- hemorrhage; 12 mTBI-non- specific white matter hyperintensities or chronic hemorrhagic contusions. Controls: 26 controls (19M, 7 7F; mean age 28.3, range 17–58). |
Analysis and Methods: ROI Analysis. Manual ROI, ellipsoid shapes for each ROI. Dependent Measures: FA. Reaction time to Attention Network Task (Fan et al., 2005). |
ROI structures: uncinate fasciculus, anterior corona radiata, anterior aspect of the inferior longitudinal fasciculus, genu of the CC, the cingulum bundle, and the superior longitudinal fasciculus. |
|
Niogi (Extension of 2008a paper) | 2008b | Subacute and Chronic. ≥1 month post-injury (mean 16.9 months, range 1–53 months). ≥ 1 persistent symptom for postconcussive syndrome. |
3T |
Patients: 43 patients (28M, 15F; mean age 32.4) [GCS 13–15]. Negative findings for conventional MRI images of 12/43 patients. Controls: 23 controls (17 M, 6F; mean age 29.9) Negative findings for conventional MRI. |
Analysis and Methods: ROI analysis. Manual ROI, ellipsoid shapes for each ROI. Dependent Measures: FA. Attention Network Task (Fan et al., 2005), California Verbal Learning Test (CVLT) to test memory performance. |
ROI structures: uncinate fasciculus, anterior corona radiata, anterior aspect of the inferior longitudinal fasciculus, genu of the CC, the cingulum bundle, and the superior longitudinal fasciculus. |
|
Rutgers | 2008a | Subacute and Chronic. Median 5.5 months (range 0.1–109.3 months). |
1.5T |
Patients: 21 mTBI patients (12M, 9F; mean age 32±9) [GCS 13–15]. 17/21 patients negative findings on MRI; others contusions and 1 extra-axial hematoma. Controls: 11 controls (8M, 3F; mean age 37±9). No known history of positive MRI findings. |
Analysis and Methods: ROI, tractography. Dependent Measures: FA, volume, ADC, number and length of through-passing fibers in each ROI, tractography measure of discontinuity. |
ROI structures: cerebral lobar white matter, cingulum, CC, anterior and posterior limb of the internal capsules, mesencephalon, brain stem, and cerebellum. Cerebral lobar white matter was subdivided into centrum semiovale, frontal lobe, parietal lobe, temporal lobe, and occipital lobe. |
|
Rutgers | 2008b | Chronic. Average 2.8 months. |
1.5T |
Patients: 39 TBI patients (27M, 12F; mean age 34±12); 24 mild [GCS 13–15]; 9, moderate [GCS 9–12]; and 6, severe TBI [GCS ≤8]. Controls: 10 controls (7M, 3F; mean age 37±9). No known history of positive MRI findings. |
Analysis and Methods: ROI analysis done by drawing ROI manually on the parts of the CC on FA maps of each subject. Dependent Measures: FA, ADC, number of fibers. |
ROI structures: CC genu, body, and splenium. |
|
Huang | 2009 | “Post-acute”. | 1.5T |
Patients: 10 patients mild TBI (mean age 25.0±11.5; mean education 12.7±4.7 years) [GCS 13–15]. 7 of 10 negative findings on conventional CT/MRI. Controls: 14 age-matched healthy subjects (mean age 27.4±15.2, mean education 12.9±3.2 years). |
Analysis and Methods: Probabilistic tractography, Tract Based Spatial Statistics, MEG Dependent Measures: MEG delta slow waves, FA |
Fronto-occipital fasciculus, superior longitudinal fasciculus, inferior longitudinal fasciculus, uncinate fasciculus, CC, and cingulum bundles. Automated Whole Brain Analysis. |
|
Lipton | 2009 | Acute. ≤ 2 weeks. |
3T |
Patients: 20 mTBI patients (9M, 11F; mean age 33.4) [CGS 13–15, LOC <20 min, PTA <24 hr]. Controls: 20 matched controls (9M, 11F; mean age 34.2). |
Analysis and Methods: Voxel-wise analysis. Dependent Measures: FA, MD. |
Automated analysis of whole brain. |
|
Lo | 2009 | Chronic. ≥ 2 years. |
1.5T |
Patients: 10 patients (5M, 5F; age range 20–51) [CGS 13–15]. For those who had conventional MR/CT, the findings were negative. Following research scan, 1 subject had a small focal area showing lobar gliosis. Controls: 10 controls (5M, 5F; mean age 44). Controls were patients referred for MRI due to headache and had no history of head trauma. |
Analysis and Methods: ROI. Dependent Measures: FA, ADC. |
ROIs placed in the genu and splenium of the CC, posterior limb of the internal capsule, and in the pontine tegmentum. |
|
Geary | 2010 | Chronic. ≥ 6 months. |
3T |
Patients: 40 mTBI patients (17M, 23F; mean age 34.53) [American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine, 1993 criteria]. 14 subjects had previous head trauma. Negative MRI/CT findings. Controls: 35 controls (16M, 19F; mean age 32.54) matched to patients on age, education, years of employment, and estimated premorbid intelligence. |
Analysis and Methods: ROI. Dependent Measures: FA. |
ROIs structures: anterior and posterior corona radiata, corticospinal tracts (including parts of the corticopontine tract and superior thalamic radiation), external capsule, cingulum, forceps minor, forceps major, inferior fronto-occipital fasciculus, superior longitudinal fasciculus, uncinate fasciculus, sagittal stratum, and body, genu, and splenium of CC. |
|
Holli(b) | 2010 | Acute. ≤ 3 weeks. |
1.5T |
Patients: 42 patients (17 M, 25F; mean age, 38.8) [GCS 13–15]. DTI analyses were performed on 34 patients. Negative CT/MRI findings. Controls: 10 age- and sex- matched controls (4M, 6F; mean age, 39.8). |
Analysis and Methods: Texture analysis (MaZda). Dependent Measures: FA, ADC. |
Regions corresponding to the mesencephalon, centrum semiovale, and CC. |
|
Maruta | 2010 | Subacute to Chronic. 6 weeks and 5 years (mean 2.7 years). |
3T |
Patients: 17 patients (10M, 7F; age range 20–52), [GCS 15 with chronic postconcussive syndrome, recruited from clinics]. 8 normal, 9 showed abnormalities. Controls: 9 controls (6M, 3F; age range 19–31). No prior history of TBI. |
Analysis and Methods: ROIs selected a priori. Dependent Measures: FA. |
Anterior corona radiata, genu of the CC, uncinate fasciculus, cingulum bundle, forceps major, and superior cerebellar peduncle. |
|
Mayer | 2010 | Acute. ≤ 21 days (mean 12 days). |
3T |
Patients: 22 patients (mean age 27.45) [GCS 13–15, LOC <30 min, PTA <24hr]. Controls: 21 sex-, age-, and education-matched controls (mean age 26.81). |
Analysis and Methods: ROI. Dependent Measures: FA, AD, RD. |
Genu, splenium, and body of the CC, as well as the superior longitudinal fasciculus, the corona radiata, the superior corona radiata, the uncinate fasciculus, and the internal capsule for both hemispheres. |
|
Zhang | 2010 | Subacute. 30 (±2) days. |
3T |
Patients: 15 student-athletes with mTBI (mean age 20.8 years) [Grade 1 MTBI according to Cantu 2006. GCS not reported]. Negative MRI findings. Controls: 15 normal student- athletes with no history of mTBI (mean age 21.3). Negative MRI findings. The entire sample was 70%M and 30%F. |
Analysis and Methods: Voxel-wise whole brain analysis and ROI. Dependent Measures: FA, ADC. |
The CC was chosen as a primary ROI and subdivided into the genu, body, and splenium. In addition, the right hippocampus, left and right dorsolateral prefrontal cortexes were evaluated. |
|
Warner | 2010b | Acute. ≤1 week Follow-up at 4–16 months. |
3T | Patients: 24 patients with diffuse traumatic axonal injury (16M, 8F; mean age 27.2) [mean GCS 6.4; range not reported]. Controls: None. |
Analysis and Methods: Automated Segmentation and Volumetric Analysis (FreeSurfer). Dependent Measures: Regional Volumes, FA, MD. |
CC, fornix body, bilateral fornix crus, bilateral perforant pathway, cingulum, uncinate fasciculus, and inferior fronto-occipital fasciculus. |
|
Bazarian | 2011 | Acute. (72 hours post-injury). Prospective cohort study. Subjects underwent DTI pre- and postseason within a 3-month interval. (Concussed subjects underwent repeat testing ≤ 72 hours of injury. Subjects who did not suffer a concussion during the season underwent repeat testing ≤ 1 week of the end of the sports season 3 months after initial testing). |
3T |
Patients: One athlete concussion [witnessed LOC >20 min, transient amnesia or confusion; GCS not reported] and 8 athletes with 26–399 subconcussive head blows. Controls: 6 control subjects. 2 control subjects had isolated minor orthopedic injuries. |
Analysis and Methods: Whole brain analysis. FA and MD changes were measured in five ROIs. Dependent Measures: FA, MD. |
External capsule, posterior and anterior CC, posterior and anterior limb of the internal capsule. |
|
Cubon | 2011 | Subacute and Chronic. ≥1 month (mean 115 days, SD 104 days) for the sports-related concussion subjects. ≥ 1 year for subjects with moderate and severe TBI. |
3T |
Patients: 10 college students with concussion (5M, 5F; mean age 19.7 years) [Diagnosis based on International Consensus Agreements 2000, GCS not reported]. 2 moderate TBI subjects (mean age 20) [GCS 9–12]. 3 severe TBI (mean age 47.3) [GCS ≤8]. Controls: 10 sex- and age- matched athletes (5M, 5F; mean age 20.4 years). Sex- and age-matched controls, for the 2 moderate (mean age 22) and 3 severe TBI subjects (mean age 46). |
Analysis and Methods: TBSS. Dependent Measures: FA, MD. |
Whole brain WM skeleton (TBSS). |
|
Davenport | 2011 | Chronic. 2–5 years after blast injury. |
3T |
Patients: 25 veterans with mTBI (24M, 1F; mean age 36) [LOC <30 min, PTA <24 hours, and neurological symptoms; GCS not reported). Controls: 33 veterans (28 M, 5F; mean age 32.5). |
Analysis and Methods: 20 standard probabilistic tractography-based ROIs. Dependent Measures: FA. |
Forceps major, forceps minor, anterior thalamic radiations, hippocampal portion of cingulum, cingulum, corticospinal tract, inferior fronto-occipital fasciculus, inferior longitudinal fasciculus, superior longitudinal fasciculus, temporal portion of superior longitudinal fasciculus, uncinate. |
|
Grossman | 2011 | Chronic. MRI and a neuropsychological battery either ≤ 1 year after injury, or >1 year after injury. |
3T |
Patients: 22 patients (14M, 8F; mean age 38.2) [GCS 13–15]. Controls: 14 healthy controls (9M, 5F; mean age 36.5) matched to patients according to gender, age, and formal education |
Analysis and Methods: ROI. Dependent Measures: MK, FA, MD. |
Thalamus and the anterior limb, genu, and posterior limb of the internal, the splenium of the CC, and the centrum semiovale. |
|
Henry | 2011 | Acute. 1–6 days post-concussion. For patients, follow-up 6 months later; for controls, 2nd scan 18 months after initial scan. |
3T |
Patients: 18 athletes with mTBI (all M; mean age 22.08) [Diagnosis based on American Academy of Neurology Quality Standards Subcommittee and Neurology, 1997; GCS not reported]. Controls: 10 athletes (all M; mean age 22.81). |
Analysis and Methods: Voxel-based approach (VBA). Dependent Measures: FA, MD, AD. |
A voxel-wise 2 × 2 repeated-measures analysis of variance (ANOVA) using SPM8 to the derived scalar images (FA, AD, and MD) was used. |
|
Lange | 2011 | Subacute. 6–8 weeks. |
3T |
Patients: 60 mTBI patients (43M, 17F; mean age 30.8) [Closed head injury and; LOC >1minute, PTA >15 minutes, GCS <15, or abnormality on CT]. n=41 negative CT findings, N=15 positive CT findings, and n=4 not ordered. N=21 with postconcussive disorder based on ICD-10; N=39 without postconcussive disorder. Controls 34 controls (25M, 9F; mean age 37.1) with orthopedic/ soft- tissue injuries. N=0 positive findings, n=3 negative findings, and n=31 not ordered. 52.9% of controls met ICD-10 criteria for postconcussive disorder. |
Analysis and Methods: ROIs. Dependent Measures: FA, MD. |
Genu, body, and splenium of the CC. |
|
MacDonald | 2011 | Subacute. ≤ 90 days. |
1.5T |
Patients: 63 patients (all M, median age 24) [Diagnosis based on U.S. military clinical criteria for traumatic brain injury; GCS not reported]. Controls: 21 controls (all M, median age 31) exposed to blasts, but none with sustained TBI. |
Analysis and Methods: ROI. Dependent Measures: Relative anisotropy (RA), MD, AD, RD. |
Genu and splenium of the CC, the right and left middle cerebellar peduncles, the right and left cerebral peduncles, the right and left uncinate fasciculi, and the right and left cingulum bundles. |
|
Matthews | 2011 | Self-reported history of concussion. | 3T |
Patients: 22 patients with a history of blast- related TBI. [LOC <30min, PTA <25 hr, CGS 13–15]. 11 TBI patients with Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) (all M, mean age 26.8). 11 TBI patients without MDD (all M, mean age 30.3). Controls: None. |
Analysis and Methods: VBA. Dependent Measures: MD, 3 Lambda values, 9 eigenvalues λ1, λ2, λ3, total MD, FA. |
|
|
Matsushita | 2011 | Acute. Median 3.5 days. |
1.5T |
Patients: 20 patients (18M, 2F; mean age 39.3): 9 mild TBI [GCS 13–15, LOC <30 min, PTA <24 hr]. 11 moderate TBI [LOC ≥30 min and/or GCS 9–12]. Controls: 27 matched controls (13M, 14F; mean age 42.9). |
Analysis and Methods: ROI. Dependent Measures: FA. |
Genu, stem, and splenium of the CC and the corona radiata, anterior limb of the internal capsule, posterior limb of the internal capsule, frontal white matter, and occipital white matter of the periventricular white matter. |
|
Messe | 2011 | Acute. 7–28 days (subacute phase), Subacute. 3–4 months (late phase). |
1.5T |
Patients: 23 patients [LOC <30 min, CGS 13–15, PTA <24 hr, or neurological symptoms]; 11 with good outcome (8M, 3F; mean age 27.8), 12 with poor outcome (7M, 5F; mean age 31.3). 7 of 11 with good outcome had negative MRI findings and 6 out of 12 poor outcome had negative MRI findings. Controls 23 controls (12M, 11F; mean age 30). |
Analysis and Methods: VBM, TBSS. Dependent Measures: FA, MD, AD, RD. |
Whole Brain. |
|
Smits | 2011 | Subacute. Average 30.6 days. |
3T |
Patients: 19 patients included (10M, 9F; mean age 26) [GCS 13–15]. Controls: 12 controls (8M, 4F; mean age 28). |
Analysis and Methods: TBSS. Dependent Measures: FA, MD. |
Whole Brain. |
|
Sponheim | 2011 | Chronic. Several Months. |
1.5T |
Patients: 9 patients (all M; mean age 33.7) [Diagnosis based on American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine Special Interest Group on Mild Traumatic Brain Injury and the concussion grading system by the American Academy of Neurology; GCS not reported]. Controls: 8 controls (all M; mean age 30.3). |
Analysis and Methods: ROI. Dependent Measures: Electroencephalogram (EEG) phase synchronization and FA. |
Forceps major, forceps major and anterior thalamic radiations. |
|
McAllister | 2012 | Acute. Preseason and ≤ 10 days of a diagnosed concussion. |
3T | Subjects: 10 athletes (all M; age range 15–23) with mTBI [Diagnosis by certified athletic trainer or team physician; GCS not reported]. Controls: None. |
Analysis and Methods: Strain and strain rate calculations based on Dartmouth Subject- Specific FE Head model (helmets worn to record head impacts during play on the field). DTI maps for CC. Dependent Measures: FA, MD, Strain, Strain Rate. |
CC. |
|
Key: M=Male; F=Female; PTA=Posttraumatic Amnesia; LOC=Loss of Consciousness; GCS=Glascow Coma Scale; CC=Corpus Callosum; ADC=Apparent Diffusion Coefficient; FA=Fractional Anisotropy; MD=Mean Diffusivity; RD=Radial Diffusivity; AD=Axial Diffusivity; DKI=Diffusional Kurtosis Imaging; DTI=Diffusion Tensor Imaging; MK=Mean Kurtosis; ROI=Region of Interest; TBSS=Tract-Based Spatial Statistics.
This table presents findings derived from diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) including: Trace, Mean Diffusivity (MD), Fractional Anisotropy (FA), Axial Diffusivity (AD), Radial Diffusivity (RD), and Mean Kurtosis (MK). In studies where non-DTI diffusion weighted imaging (DWI) was also presented we include the main measure, Apparent Diffusion Coefficient (ADC). In the description of subjects, we provide, when available, the Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score, Loss of Consciousness (LOC) duration, and Posttraumatic Amnesia (PTA) duration. Acute is defined as under 1 month, subacute is defined as >1 month but less than 6 months, and chronic is defined as >6 months.