Table A6: Risk of Bias Among Observational Trials for the Impact of eTools.
Author, Year | Appropriate Eligibility Criteria | Appropriate Measurement of Exposure | Appropriate Measurement of Outcome | Adequate Control for Confounding | Complete Follow-Up |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Branger et al, 1999 (32) | Serious limitationsa | No limitations | No limitations | No limitations | No limitations |
Cebul et al, 2011 (38) | Serious limitationsb | No limitations | No limitations | No limitationsc | No limitations |
Crosson et al, 2012 (39) | Serious limitationsb | No limitations | No limitations | No limitationsc | Serious limitationsd |
Henderson et al, 2010 (36) | Serious limitationsb | No limitations | No limitations | No limitationsc | No limitationse |
Herrin et al, 2012 (40) | Serious limitationsf | No limitations | No limitations | No limitationsc | No limitationsg |
Walsh et al, 2012 (41) | Serious limitationsb | No limitations | No limitations | No limitationsc | No limitations |
Wells et al, 1996 (42) | Serious limitationsb | No limitations | No limitations | No limitations | Serious limitationsd |
Abbreviation: EHR, electronic health record; EMR, electronic medical record; eTools, electronic tools.
Physicians with greatest number of referrals were provided with the electronic intervention, while the others were considered the control group.
Physicians self-selected to use EMRs (or other electronic intervention) and therefore may inherently be different from those who did not.
Statistical modelling was applied to adjust for known or otherwise potential confounding factors.
Intervention was implemented at the level of physician practice, and this resulted in some flux of individual patients within both study groups.
Assessment was conducted at the level of patient encounter; individual patients were not accounted for.
Unknown methodology for selecting practices which were early adopters to EHR and up to 5 years later adoption, introducing potential bias in physician practice type.
Results accounted patient years, not individual patients.