Skip to main content
. 2013 Sep 1;13(9):1–60.

Table A1: Study Design Characteristics.

Study, Year Country Design Arms, n Attrition, % Recruitment Length of Follow-up Patient Eligibility Criteria Control
Lorig et al, 1999 (4) United States Single-blind RCT Randomized
Total: 1,140
SM: 664
UC: 476

Completed
Total: 952
SM: 561
UC: 391
15.1 SM
17.9 UC
  • Self-selection

  • Community

  • Public service announcements, flyers, posters, newsletters, and referrals from government employers

6 months Chronic diseases: physician-confirmed asthma, CAD, CHF, chronic arthritis, chronic bronchitis, emphysema, or stroke
Inclusion criteria: 1 or more of above chronic diseases
Exclusion criteria: compromised mentation; received chemotherapy or radiation within past year for cancer; < 40 years age
Waiting-list control
Fu et al, 2003 (17) China Single-blind RCT Randomized
Total: 954
SM: 526
UC: 428

Completed
Total: 779
SM: 430
UC: 349
18.3 SM
18.5 UC
  • Self-selection

  • Community

  • Public service announcements, flyers, posters, interpersonal persuasion

6 months Chronic diseases: medical record-confirmed arthritis, asthma, CAD, CHF, chronic bronchitis, diabetes, emphysema, hypertension, or stroke
Inclusion criteria: 1 or more of above chronic diseases; ≥ 20 years age
Exclusion criteria: compromised mentation; received chemotherapy or radiation within past year for cancer; patients for whom problems could be expected with compliance or follow-up; participation in another study in previous 30 days; stroke with severe physical disability ;< 20 years of age
Waiting-list control
Lorig et al, 2003 (15) United States Single-blind RCT Randomized
Total: 551
SM: 327
UC: 224

Completed
Total: 443
SM: 265
UC: 178
19.0 SM
20.5 UC
  • Self-selection

  • Community

  • Outreach

4 months Chronic diseases: physician-confirmed (self-reported if physician unavailable) heart disease, lung disease, or type 2 diabetes
Inclusion criteria: 1 or more of above chronic diseases
Exclusion criteria: treated for cancer in last year
Waiting-list control
Griffiths et al, 2005 (19) United Kingdom Double-blind RCT Randomized
Total: 476
SM: 238
UC: 238

Completed
Total: 439
SM: 221
UC: 218
7.1 SM
8.4 UC
  • Direct invitation

  • General practice registry

  • Letters followed by telephone calls

4 months Chronic diseases: registry-confirmed arthritis, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, or respiratory disease
Inclusion criteria: 1 or more of above chronic diseases; Bangladeshi; > 20 years age
Waiting-list control
Lorig et al, 2006 (14) United States Non-blind RCT Randomized
Total: 958
SM: 457
UC: 501

Completed
Total: 780
SM: 354
UC: 426
22.5 SM
17.6 UC
  • Self-selection

  • Community

  • Links to study website, calendar announcements, and articles in newspapers

12 months Chronic diseases: physician-confirmed chronic lung disease, heart disease, or type 2 diabetes
Inclusion criteria: 1 or more of above chronic diseases; ≥ 18 years age; no active treatment for cancer; not ever participated in small-group CDSMP; access to a computer; agreed to 1-2 hours per week of log-on time spread over at least 3 sessions per week for 6 weeks; able to complete online questionnaire
Care from usual provider
Swerissen et al, 2006 (16) Australia Non-blind RCT Randomized
Total: 728
SM: 467
UC: 261

Completed
Total: 474
SM: 320
UC: 154
31.5 SM
41.0 UC
  • Self-selection

  • Community

  • Public service announcements, posters, brochures, newsletters, community festivals, open days, local presentations, referrals from health professionals

6 months Chronic diseases: physician-confirmed chronic illness (not defined) or chronic pain
Inclusion criteria: 1 or more of above chronic diseases; ≥ 18 years age; Italian, Greek, Vietnamese, or Chinese; live within municipal areas of Boroondara, Darebin, Hume, Greater Dandenong, Yarra, or Whittlesea
Exclusion criteria: < 18 years age; primary illness psychological or advanced neurological disorder
Waiting-list control
Elzen et al, 2007 (18) Netherlands Non-blind RCT Randomized
Total: 144
SM: 70
UC: 74

Completed
Total: 129
SM: 67
UC: 62
4.3 SM
16.2 UC
  • Direct invitation/ self-selection

  • Outpatient clinic

  • Public service announcements, magazine ads

6 months Chronic diseases: angina pectoris, arthritis, asthma, CHF, COPD, diabetes (unclear how diagnosis confirmed)
Inclusion criteria: 1 or more of the above chronic diseases; ≥59 years of age; ability to communicate in Dutch; availability to attend a 6-week course
Exclusion criteria: life expectancy of less than 1 year; already attending a disease-specific self-management program; participating in another study; permanent residents of a nursing home
Waiting-list control
Kennedy et al, 2007 (12) United Kingdom Non-blind RCT Randomized
Total: 629
SM: 313
UC: 316

Completed
Total: 521
SM: 248
UC: 273
20.8 SM
13.6 UC
  • Self-selection

  • Community

  • Recruitment through EPP, primary care trust staff, press releases, and EPP web page

6 months Chronic diseases: self-reported chronic condition (not defined)
Inclusion criteria: 1 or more self-reported chronic condition
Waiting-list control
Jerant et al, 2009 (10) United States Non-blind RCT Randomized
Total: 415
Intervention A: 138
Intervention B: 139
UC: 138

Completed
Total: 415
Intervention A: 138
Intervention B: 139
UC: 138
15.9 SM
14.4 T
7.2 UC
  • Self-selection/direct invitation

  • Primary care

  • Announcements and telephone calls

12 months
Chronic diseases: physician-confirmed arthritis, asthma, COPD, CHF, depression, or diabetes
Inclusion criteria: 1 or more of above chronic disease; ≥40 years age; ability to speak and read in English; residence in a private home with active telephone; eyesight and hearing adequate; at least 1 activity impairment assessed by the HAQ and/or a score of ≥4 on the 10-item CES-D
Care from their usual provider
Hochhalter et al, 2010 (13) United States Single-blind RCT Randomized
Total: 79
SM: 26
Safety group: 27
UC: 26

Completed
Total: 64
SM: 20
Safety group: 23
UC: 21
23.1 SM
14.8 S
19.2 UC
  • Direct invitation

  • Primary care clinic

  • Letters

6 months Chronic diseases: ICD-9 diagnosis arthritis, depression, diabetes, heart disease, hypertension, lung disease, or osteoporosis
Inclusion criteria: received treatment for at least 2 of the above chronic conditions in the previous 12 months; ≥ 65 years age; can communicate in English; has access to telephone; expected to receive most of their care within the health care system for at least 8 months prior to baseline
Exclusion criteria: diagnosed with dementia; receiving hospice care; unable to travel to clinic; living outside of the recruitment area
Care from usual care provider

Abbreviations: CAD, coronary artery disease; CDSMP, Chronic Disease Self-Management Program; CES–D, Center for Epidemiologic Studies–Depression; CHF, congestive heart failure; COPD, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; EPP, Expert Patient Programme; HAQ, Health Assessment Questionnaire; ICD-9, International Classification of Diseases, 9th Edition; RCT, randomized controlled trial; S, safety arm; SM, self-management arm; T, telephone arm; UC, usual care arm.