Skip to main content
. 2013 Nov 12;8(11):e74186. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0074186

Table 3. Outcome measures of group A (studies not focused on impacted teeth).

First author Year Number of patients Characteristics of patients Number and type of examiners Reference Standard Index test Occasions (interval)
Record set versus 2D X-rays on demand
Atchison KA [10] 1991 6 3× Class I and 3× Class II 39 ortho anamnesis+dental casts+extra- and intraoral photographs anamnesis+dental casts+extra- and intraoral photographs with extra X-ray radiography on demand 1
Atchison KA [11] 1992 6 3× Class I and 3× Class II 39 ortho anamnesis+dental casts+extra- and intraoral photographs anamnesis+dental casts+extra- and intraoral photographs with extra X-ray radiography on demand 1
Bruks A [12] 1999 70 Class I and Class II 4 pgs anamnesis+dental casts+extra- and intraoral photographs anamnesis+dental casts+extra- and intraoral photographs with extra X-ray radiography on demand 1
Record set versus lateral headplate
Greenhill R [13] 1979 30 11 (4 ortho; 4 dent; 1 period; 2 admini) dental casts+LHP+tracing+colour photographs 1) dental cast; 2) dental casts+LHP+tracing 3 (4–5 weeks)
Silling G [14] 1979 6 2× Class II/2, 2× Class I, 2× Class II/1 24 ortho dental casts+extra oral photographs+periapical radiographs+LHP+tracing dental casts+extra oral photographs+periapical radiographs 1
Han UK [15] 1991 57 Class II/1 5 ortho dental casts+extra oral photographs+OPT+LHP+tracing 1) dental casts; 2) dental casts+extra oral photo's; 3) dental casts+extra oral photo's+OPG; 4) dental casts+extra oral photo's+OPG+LHP 5 (1 month)
Pae EK [16] 2001 80 Class I, Class II/2, Class III, open bites, bimaxillary protrusion 16 ortho dental casts+LHP (no tracing) dental casts 2 (minimal 1 week)
Nijkamp PG [17] 2008 48 Class II 14 (4 ortho; 10 pgs) dental casts+LHP+tracing dental casts 4 (≥1 month)
Devereux L [18] 2011 6 2× Class I, 3× Class II, 1× Class III 199–>114 ortho anamnesis+dental casts+extra- and intraoral photographs+OPT+LHP+tracing anamnesis+dental casts+extra- and intraoral photographs+OPT 2 (8 weeks)
Plaster casts versus digital casts
Rheude B [19] 2005 30->7 selected 7 ortho Medical and dental history+extra- and intraoral pictures+OPT+LHP+plaster casts Medical and dental history+extra- and intraoral pictures+OPT+LHP+digital casts 2 (maximal 30 minutes)
Whetten JL [20] 2006 10 Class II 20 ortho Extraoral photographs+OPT+LHP+tracing+plaster casts Extraoral photographs+OPT+LHP+tracing+digital casts 2 (≥1 month)
Plaster casts without articulator versus plaster casts with articulator
Ellis PE [21] 2003 20 10 ortho Extraoral photographs+OPT+LHP+tracing+plaster casts Extraoral photographs+OPT+LHP+tracing+plaster casts articulated in the articulator 3 (minimal 2 weeks)

ortho = orthodontist(s); pgs = postgraduate(s); dent = dentist(s); period = periodontist(s); admini = administrative personnel; LHP = lateral headplate; OPT = orthopantomogram; 2D = two-dimensional.