Table 3.
Base-case results
Screening strategy | Cost, $ | Effectiveness, QALYs | Marginal cost, $ | Marginal effectiveness QALYs | Marginal cost-effectiveness ratio, $/QALY |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Primary Model: Discounted (3% per year) | |||||
No screen | 2,200.96 | 29.33559 | - | - | - |
Questionnaire/TST if + | 2,218.20 | 29.33555 | 17.24 | −0.00004 | dominated |
Universal TST | 2,480.97 | 29.33471 | 280.01 | −0.00088 | dominated |
Primary Model: Non-discounted | |||||
No screen | 2,216.16 | 71.75844 | - | - | |
Questionnaire/TST if + | 2,228.69 | 71.75839 | 12.53 | −0.00005 | dominated |
Universal TST | 2,485.93 | 71.75731 | 269.76 | −0.00113 | dominated |
Secondary Model: Discounted (3% per year) | |||||
No screen | 2,200.96 | 29.33559 | |||
Questionnaire/IGRA if + | 2,208.01 | 29.33560 | 7.05 | 0.00001 | 705,000 |
Questionnaire/TST if + | 2,218.20 | 29.33555 | 10.02 | −0.00005 | dominated |
TST/IGRA if + | 2,272.43 | 29.33558 | 64.42 | −0.00002 | dominated |
Universal IGRA | 2,304.89 | 29.33553 | 96.88 | −0.00007 | dominated |
Universal TST | 2,480.97 | 29.33471 | 272.97 | −0.00089 | dominated |
Secondary Model: Non-discounted | |||||
No screen | 2,216.16 | 71.75844 | - | - | - |
Questionnaire/IGRA if + | 2,218.68 | 71.75845 | 2.52 | 0.00001 | 252,000 |
Questionnaire/TST if + | 2,228.69 | 71.75839 | 10.01 | −0.00006 | dominated |
TST/IGRA if + | 2,278.77 | 71.75844 | 60.09 | −0.00001 | dominated |
Universal IGRA | 2,310.25 | 71.75836 | 91.57 | −0.00009 | dominated |
Universal TST | 2,485.93 | 71.75731 | 267.24 | −0.00114 | dominated |
Dominated indicates the strategy is both more costly and less/equally effective compared to the next best strategy
Abbreviation: QALY, quality-adjusted life-year; ; IGRA, interferon-γ release assay; TST, tuberculin skin testing