Skip to main content
. 2012 Sep;43(3):329–336. doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2012.05.026

Table 2.

Quality assessment of the included studies

Author Selection bias Measurement bias
Confounding Overall (0–4)a
Retirement Physical activity
Berger (2005)22 No Yes Yes ? 1
Brown (2009)23 Yes No No Yes 2
Chung (2009)24 No No Yes No 3
Evenson (2002)25 Yes No No Yes 2
Fonseca (2004)26 Yes No Yes Yes 1
Glamser (1985)27 Yes No Yes Yes 1
Henkens (2008)28 Yes No Yes ? 1
Mein (2005)29 No No Yes No 3
Midanik (1995)30 No No Yes Yes 2
Parnes (1985)31 Yes No Yes No 2
Patrick (1985)32 Yes ? No Yes 1
Slingerland (2007)33 Yes No Yes No 2
Touvier (2010)34 Yes No No Yes 2
Wells (1999)35 No No Yes Yes 2
Wister (1996)36 No No Yes ? 2
Chung (2005)37 No No Yes No 3
Nekuda (2007)38 ? ? Yes No 1
Parise (2006)39 ? Yes Yes Yes 0
Zheng (2008)40 ? No Yes No 2

Note: ?, not reported; studies ordered by type (published articles followed by PhD theses) and then alphabetically by first author

a

0–1 indicates low quality; 2 indicates modest quality; 3–4 indicates high quality.