Table 7.
The syndrome differentiation of the three physicians at the first treatment.
| Random number | Physician A | Physician B | Physician C |
|---|---|---|---|
| 06 | Kidney deficiency | (i) Blood stasis (ii) Blood not nourish heart and disturbing heart-mind |
(i) Stagnation of qi and blood stasis (ii) Dampness |
| 21 | (i) Kidney deficiency (ii) Exuberance of liver (iii) Dampness blockage |
Phlegm-heat | Blood stasis |
| 23 | (i) Kidney deficiency (ii) Exuberance of liver (iii) Dampness due to the deficiency of spleen |
(i) Disharmony between heart and kidney (ii) Heat disturbing heart-mind |
(i) Discomfort in stomach and spleen (ii) Qi deficiency of heart and gallbladder |
| 25 | Discomfort in stomach | (i) Endogenous heat due to Yin deficiency (ii) Heat disturbing heart-mind |
(i) Kidney deficiency (ii) Exuberance of liver (iii) Disharmony between heart and kidney |
| 15 | (i) Qi and blood deficiency (ii) Malnutrition of heart-mind |
(i) Endogenous heat due to Yin deficiency (ii) Heat disturbing heart-mind |
Fever due to deficiency |
| 17 | (i) Qi and blood deficiency (ii) Endogenous heat due to Yin deficiency (iii) Heat disturbing heart-mind |
Blood not nourish heart | (i) Yin deficiency of liver and kidney (ii) Disharmony between heart and kidney |
| 29 | (i) Kidney deficiency (ii) Liver heat (iii) Stomach stagnation |
Phlegm-heat disturbing heart-mind | (i) Phlegm-heat disturbing heart mind (ii) Dampness-heat |
| 01 | Blood deficiency and liver stagnation | (i) Phlegm-damp transform into heat (ii) Heat disturbing heart-mind |
Liver stagnation and deficiency of spleen |
| 05 | Phlegm-heat disturbing heart-mind | Phlegm-heat disturbing heart-mind | Yin deficiency of heart |
| 13 | (i) Yin deficiency (ii) Liver and stomach depression transforming into heat |
Phlegm-heat disturbing heart-mind | (i) Blood deficiency of liver and heart (ii) Hyperactivity of fire due to yin deficiency |
| 08 | Kidney deficiency | (i) Disharmony between heart and kidney (ii) Phlegm-heat disturbing heart-mind |
(i) Qi deficiency of heart and gallbladder (ii) Qi stagnation hurt heart-mind |
| 18 | Phlegm-heat | Phlegm-heat disturbing heart-mind | Yin deficiency of liver and Kidney |
| 27 | (i) Kidney deficiency (ii) Exuberance of liver |
(i) Blood stasis (ii) Heat disturbing heart-mind |
(i) Phlegm-fire disturbing heart (ii) Dampness-heat diffused downward |
| 28 | (i) Liver stagnation (ii) Blood deficiency |
(i) Blood stasis (ii) Blood not nourishing heart |
Liver stagnation and deficiency of spleen |
| 33 | (i) Liver stagnation (ii) Blood deficiency (iii) Syndrome of fu-viscera of Yang ming |
(i) Blood stasis (ii) Heat disturbing heart-mind |
Stagnation of qi and blood stasis |
| 20 | (i) Blood deficiency (ii) Liver stagnation (iii) Phlegm disturbance |
(i) Disharmony between heart and kidney (ii) Heat disturbing heart-mind |
Blood deficiency of liver and heart |
| 03 | Blood deficiency and liver stagnation | (i) Endogenous heat due to Yin deficiency (ii) Heat disturbing heart-mind |
Blood stasis |
| 04 | Stagnant heat of liver and stomach | (i) Disharmony between heart and kidney (ii) Phlegm-heat disturbing heart |
Liver fire flaring up |
| 10 | Kidney deficiency and liver stagnation | (i) Disharmony between heart and kidney (ii) Blood not nourishing heart |
Yin deficiency of liver and kidney |
| 14 | (i) Qi and blood deficiency (ii) Stagnant heat of liver and stomach |
(i) Blood not nourishing heart (ii) Endogenous heat due to Yin deficiency |
Blood stasis |
| 16 | (i) Blood deficiency (ii) Exuberance of liver (iii) Phlegm blockage |
(i) Disharmony between heart and kidney (ii) Heat disturbing heart-mind |
Dampness-heat diffused downward |
| 19 | (i) Qi deficiency of heart and gallbladder (ii) Phlegm blockage |
Phlegm-heat disturbing heart-mind | (i) Qi deficiency of heart and gallbladder (ii) Endogenous heat due to gallbladder heat (iii) Blood stasis |
| 26 | (i) Qi and blood deficiency (ii) Exuberance of liver disturbing heart-mind |
(i) Disharmony between heart and kidney (ii) Endogenous heat due to Yin deficiency |
Blood stasis |
| 30 | (i) Liver stagnation and deficiency of spleen (ii) Exuberance of liver |
(i) Blood not nourishing heart (ii) Endogenous heat |
Blood deficiency of liver and heart |
| 32 | (i) Kidney deficiency (ii) Exuberance of liver |
Phlegm-heat | Phlegm-heat |
| 24 | (i) Blood deficiency (ii) Exuberance of liver |
(i) Blood stasis (ii) Phlegm-heat disturbing heart-mind |
Liver stagnation and deficiency of spleen |