Table 1.
Technique
|
Detects...
|
Benefits
|
Drawbacks
|
References
|
---|---|---|---|---|
Nitrocellulose membrane binding assay Electrophoretic mobility shift assay |
In vitro interaction between protein and ‘naked’ DNA | Simple and convenient Can discriminate between direct and indirect interactions |
Not conclusive of in vivo interactions Low throughput |
Damm et al. (1989) and Umesono et al. (1991) |
DNase footprinting | Protein interaction with DNA at high resolution | Nucleotide level resolution allows precise identification of binding sites or nucleosome occupancy |
In vitro assays are low throughput and are not conclusive of in vivo functionality In vivo approaches cannot identify bound protein |
Payvar et al. (1983) and Gross & Garrard (1988) |
Reporter assay | Ability of specific DNA sequence to activate, enhance, or repress transcription | Indicates transcriptional functionality of the DNA sequence in question | Sequence is placed out of context and may not reflect in vivo properties | Umesono et al. (1991) |
Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) | Presence of specific protein at a specific location in vivo |
In vivo system Allows observation of highly dynamic events |
Requires a population of cells, so observations are not necessarily concurrent in a single cell Cannot directly indicate functional significance Interactions may be indirect |
Orlando (2000) and Collas (2010) |
ChIP–reChIP | Co-localization of two proteins at a specific genomic locus | Highly suggestive of functional relationship between two proteins at the chromatin level | Reduced signal to noise ratio Requires high quality antibodies |
Furlan-Magaril et al. (2009) |
μChIP | Presence of a specific protein and a specific location in vivo with as few as 100 cells | Low amount of starting material | Requires high-quality antibodies and high abundance protein | Collas (2010) |
ChIP-chip ChIP-seq |
Presence of a specific protein throughout a large portion or the entire genome | High throughput | Considerable variation between experiments Highly dependent on the quality of antibody Cannot directly indicate functional significance |
Collas (2010) |
ChIA–PET | Chromatin looping and interaction of distal loci of the genome due to a protein of interest | Identifies chromatin looping associated with protein of interest | Cannot demonstrate whether looping depends on the protein of interest Low signal to noise ratio |
de Wit & de Laat (2012) |