Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2013 Nov 25.
Published in final edited form as: J Mol Endocrinol. 2012 Sep 5;49(2):10.1530/JME-12-0016. doi: 10.1530/JME-12-0016

Table 1.

Various techniques used to analyze transcription factor interactions with DNA, along with their benefits and shortcomings. This list is not meant to be exhaustive

Technique
Detects...
Benefits
Drawbacks
References
Nitrocellulose membrane binding assay
Electrophoretic mobility shift assay
In vitro interaction between protein and ‘naked’ DNA Simple and convenient
Can discriminate between direct and indirect interactions
Not conclusive of in vivo interactions
Low throughput
Damm et al. (1989) and Umesono et al. (1991)
DNase footprinting Protein interaction with DNA at high resolution Nucleotide level resolution allows precise identification of binding sites or nucleosome occupancy In vitro assays are low throughput and are not conclusive of in vivo functionality
In vivo approaches cannot identify bound protein
Payvar et al. (1983) and Gross & Garrard (1988)
Reporter assay Ability of specific DNA sequence to activate, enhance, or repress transcription Indicates transcriptional functionality of the DNA sequence in question Sequence is placed out of context and may not reflect in vivo properties Umesono et al. (1991)
Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) Presence of specific protein at a specific location in vivo In vivo system
Allows observation of highly dynamic events
Requires a population of cells, so observations are not necessarily concurrent in a single cell
Cannot directly indicate functional significance
Interactions may be indirect
Orlando (2000) and Collas (2010)
ChIP–reChIP Co-localization of two proteins at a specific genomic locus Highly suggestive of functional relationship between two proteins at the chromatin level Reduced signal to noise ratio
Requires high quality antibodies
Furlan-Magaril et al. (2009)
μChIP Presence of a specific protein and a specific location in vivo with as few as 100 cells Low amount of starting material Requires high-quality antibodies and high abundance protein Collas (2010)
ChIP-chip
ChIP-seq
Presence of a specific protein throughout a large portion or the entire genome High throughput Considerable variation between experiments
Highly dependent on the quality of antibody
Cannot directly indicate functional significance
Collas (2010)
ChIA–PET Chromatin looping and interaction of distal loci of the genome due to a protein of interest Identifies chromatin looping associated with protein of interest Cannot demonstrate whether looping depends on the protein of interest
Low signal to noise ratio
de Wit & de Laat (2012)