Table. Summary of Selected Recent or Pending Heart Failure with Preserved Ejection Fraction Randomized Controlled Trials.
Trial | Intervention | HFpEF patient type* | Primary endpoint | Trial result | Trial “Matched” for Rx? |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kosmala et al. | Ivabradine | Exercise-induced DD | Peak VO2, peak E/e’ | Positive | Yes |
CHAMPION | CardioMEMS sensor | Volume overload | HF hospitalization | Positive | Yes |
Guazzi et al. | Sildenafil | Right heart failure / PH | Pulmonary hemodynamics, RV performance, QoL |
Positive | Yes |
Kitzman et al. | Exercise training | Exercise-induced DD | Peak VO2 | Positive | Yes |
PARAMOUN T |
LCZ696 (ARNI) | Volume overload | ΔNT-proBNP | Positive | Yes |
TOPCAT | Sprionolactone | Volume overload | CV death, aborted cardiac arrest, or HF hospitalization |
Pending | Yes‡ |
ALDO-DHF | Spironolactone | Exercise-induced DD | Peak VO2, ΔE/e’ | Negative† | No‡ |
ELANDD | Nebivolol | Exercise-induced DD | 6-minute walk test | Negative | No§ |
J-DHF | Carvedilol (low-dose) | Exercise-induced DD / volume overload |
Death or HF hospitalization | Negative | No§ |
RAAM-PEF | Eplerenone | Volume overload | 6-minute walk test | Negative | No‡ |
RELAX | Sildenafil | Volume overload | Peak VO2 | Negative | No |
HFpEF = heart failure with preserved ejection fraction; Rx = treatment; ARNI = angiotensin receptor-neprilysin inhibitor; DD = diastolic dysfunction; PH= pulmonary hypertension; HF = heart failure; RV = right ventricle; QoL = quality of life; NT-proBNP = change in N-terminal pro-B-type natriuretic peptide; CV = cardiovascular
HFpEF patient types include exercise-induced diastolic dysfunction (ambulatory patients with NYHA class II-III symptoms, grade I diastolic dysfunction, and normal or near-normal BNP levels); chronic volume overload (NYHA class II-IV symptoms with history of heart failure hospitalization, elevated BNP, and/or left atrial enlargement); and associated right heart failure / pulmonary hypertension (NYHA class III-IV symptoms with evidence of pulmonary vascular disease and/or right ventricular dysfunction). See also Figure for examples of each patient type.
ALDO-DHF had co-primary end-points and was negative for the peak VO2 endpoint but positive for the ΔE/e’ endpoint.
Prior HF trials of mineralocorticoid receptor antagonists have shown that these drugs reduce volume overload and improve symptoms, but they do not improve exercise capacity or functional class.
Given the vasodilating effects of nebivolol and carvedilol, ELANDD and J-DHF may have been better suited with chronic volume overload type of patients with HF hospitalization as an endpoint; J-DHF may have proven to be positive if higher doses of carvedilol were used in the study.