Table 3.
Microarray |
Algorithms |
Apparent error |
B1 Error |
Gap estimate |
B.632+ Error |
||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
data sets | /Methods | Error | miRNAs | Error | miRNAs | Error | miRNAs | Error | miRNAs |
|
Golub et al. |
0.000 |
19 |
0.194 |
32 |
0.258 |
32 |
0.146 |
32 |
|
Lasso |
0.056 |
2 |
0.266 |
2 |
0.125 |
2 |
0.229 |
2 |
|
Boosting |
0.000 |
5 |
0.113 |
10 |
0.090 |
10 |
0.094 |
10 |
GSE17681 |
InfoGain |
0.000 |
6 |
0.154 |
21 |
0.290 |
21 |
0.111 |
21 |
|
mRMR |
0.000 |
10 |
0.175 |
28 |
0.267 |
28 |
0.129 |
28 |
|
RSMRMS |
0.000 |
8 |
0.142 |
24 |
0.299 |
24 |
0.102 |
24 |
|
μHEM |
0.000 |
5 |
0.120 |
50 |
0.325 |
50 |
0.084 |
50 |
|
Golub et al. |
0.000 |
6 |
0.116 |
48 |
0.363 |
48 |
0.081 |
48 |
|
Lasso |
0.024 |
3 |
0.102 |
3 |
0.241 |
2 |
0.079 |
3 |
|
Boosting |
0.000 |
4 |
0.037 |
9 |
0.170 |
9 |
0.025 |
9 |
GSE17846 |
InfoGain |
0.000 |
7 |
0.093 |
37 |
0.387 |
37 |
0.063 |
37 |
|
mRMR |
0.000 |
3 |
0.101 |
48 |
0.379 |
48 |
0.069 |
48 |
|
RSMRMS |
0.000 |
2 |
0.093 |
39 |
0.386 |
39 |
0.064 |
39 |
|
μHEM |
0.000 |
2 |
0.087 |
49 |
0.392 |
49 |
0.059 |
49 |
|
Golub et al. |
0.000 |
35 |
0.069 |
48 |
0.368 |
39 |
0.047 |
48 |
|
Lasso |
0.043 |
5 |
0.061 |
6 |
0.074 |
6 |
0.057 |
6 |
|
Boosting |
0.099 |
3 |
0.107 |
3 |
0.074 |
3 |
0.104 |
3 |
GSE21036 |
InfoGain |
0.000 |
39 |
0.073 |
50 |
0.372 |
44 |
0.049 |
50 |
|
mRMR |
0.000 |
19 |
0.064 |
49 |
0.376 |
50 |
0.043 |
49 |
|
RSMRMS |
0.050 |
5 |
0.089 |
5 |
0.328 |
5 |
0.075 |
5 |
|
μHEM |
0.000 |
42 |
0.058 |
47 |
0.386 |
47 |
0.039 |
47 |
|
Boosting |
0.099 |
8 |
0.211 |
8 |
0.057 |
8 |
0.192 |
8 |
|
InfoGain |
0.000 |
26 |
0.257 |
45 |
0.218 |
46 |
0.203 |
45 |
GSE24709 |
mRMR |
0.000 |
24 |
0.245 |
50 |
0.229 |
50 |
0.191 |
50 |
|
RSMRMS |
0.141 |
11 |
0.402 |
11 |
0.123 |
2 |
0.366 |
11 |
|
μHEM |
0.000 |
20 |
0.234 |
49 |
0.241 |
49 |
0.180 |
49 |
|
Golub et al. |
0.000 |
27 |
0.300 |
27 |
0.173 |
3 |
0.248 |
27 |
|
Lasso |
0.045 |
4 |
0.251 |
4 |
0.118 |
4 |
0.215 |
4 |
|
Boosting |
0.023 |
7 |
0.191 |
8 |
0.131 |
4 |
0.160 |
8 |
GSE28700 |
InfoGain |
0.000 |
35 |
0.309 |
8 |
0.159 |
8 |
0.271 |
21 |
|
mRMR |
0.000 |
21 |
0.333 |
49 |
0.140 |
7 |
0.285 |
49 |
|
RSMRMS |
0.023 |
34 |
0.331 |
19 |
0.140 |
15 |
0.285 |
19 |
|
μHEM |
0.000 |
25 |
0.306 |
4 |
0.194 |
4 |
0.257 |
4 |
|
Golub et al. |
0.000 |
36 |
0.073 |
1 |
0.364 |
1 |
0.069 |
1 |
|
Lasso |
0.061 |
3 |
0.072 |
4 |
0.184 |
1 |
0.068 |
4 |
|
Boosting |
0.081 |
2 |
0.087 |
2 |
0.085 |
1 |
0.085 |
2 |
GSE31408 |
InfoGain |
0.007 |
20 |
0.090 |
9 |
0.331 |
1 |
0.077 |
27 |
|
mRMR |
0.000 |
37 |
0.094 |
6 |
0.331 |
1 |
0.074 |
6 |
|
RSMRMS |
0.061 |
2 |
0.086 |
6 |
0.336 |
2 |
0.077 |
6 |
μHEM | 0.000 | 44 | 0.098 | 2 | 0.354 | 50 | 0.067 | 50 |