Skip to main content
. 2013 Dec 5;8(12):e81234. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0081234

Table 2. Recommended methodological guidelines for future studies.

Criteria Description Checklist
Experimental methods
Inclusion of suitable controls (non-chemotherapy cancer patients with similar demographics). To account for cytokine levels and cognitive impairment in cancer patients without chemotherapy. Did the study include controls who do not require chemotherapy, and who had the identical type of cancer and demographics as the sample population?
Account for co-morbidities To account for changes in cytokine levels and cognitive impairment as a result of chemotherapy, rather than other factors. Did the study account for non-cancer disease states?
(anemia, depression, anxiety, Alzheimer's disease, multiple sclerosis, Parkinson's, dementia, traumatic brain injury, etc.).
Account for other forms of treatment than chemotherapy. To account for changes in cytokine levels and cognitive impairment as a result of chemotherapy, rather than other forms of treatment. Did the study account for patients who were receiving other forms of therapy that may affect cytokine levels and cognitive impairment?
(hormonal therapy, cytokine therapy, radiation, antidepressants, etc.).
Chemotherapy information
Inclusion of specific chemotherapeutic agents or regimens for assessment. To understand the pharmacological effects of cytokine-induced cognitive impairment. Did the study provide clear data regarding the type of chemotherapeutic drugs/regimen involved, the duration, cycles, doses, dose intensity and route of administration of the chemotherapy treatment?
Inclusion of specific dose intensity, route of administration and duration of chemotherapeutic treatment. To understand whether there is a correlation between route of administration/strength and duration of dosing with cytokine levels and cognitive impairment.
Cytokine measurement
Inclusion of both pre-chemotherapy baseline and post-chemotherapy assessments at appropriate intervals. To account for changes in cytokine levels as a result of chemotherapy by comparing baseline measurement with post-chemotherapy measurement. Were measurements carried out before and after patients received chemotherapy/surgery?
If applicable, inclusion of pre-surgical baseline and post-surgical assessments at appropriate intervals. To account for changes in cytokine levels as a result of tumor progression/tumor load by comparing pre-surgical measurement with post-surgical measurement.
Inclusion of specific cytokines involved in the study. To identify the specific cytokine and its effects on cognitive impairment. Did the study specify the types of cytokines to be tested for?
Accounting for accuracy of testing. To minimize discrepancies in results due to the handling and processing of samples. Did the study utilize published procedures for the testing of cytokine levels?
Inclusion of standardized timing across the samples for extraction of blood samples. Different timings of extraction may result in different levels of cytokines. Did the study indicate a specific time for the extraction of cytokines from the sample and control population?