Skip to main content
. 2013 Dec 17;11(12):e1001738. doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.1001738

Table 2. Study characteristics accounting for heterogeneity of motor score.

Motor Score Effect size % (95% CI) Number of Animals Number of Comparisons Adjusted R2 p<
Pooled estimate 27.2 (25.0–29.4) 5,628 312
NBS Motor tests −8.1 (−37.7–21.4) 49 3 12.24% 0.00001
Staircase −2.0 (−43.3–39.3) 12 1
BMS 24.5 (11.2–37.7) 196 10
Multiple tests 24.5 (17.8–31.2) 1,053 56
BBB 26.7 (23.9–29.4) 4,042 228
Forelimb placing test 47.9 (18.8–77.1) 76 5
Tarlov 73.1 (57.5–88.7) 200 9
Location of injury Cervical 32.2 (12.2–52.3) 156 13 10.64% 0.00001
Lowerthoracic/lumbar 48.1 (39.7–56.5) 456 28
Midthoracic 24.9 (22.3–27.5) 5,016 271
Sex Female 22.9 (19.6–26.3) 2,906 171 9.69% 0.00001
Male 27.4 (21.7–33.1) 1,704 87
Unknown 35.7 (27.9–43.5) 676 37
Both 48.7 (37.6–59.7) 341 17
Immunosuppression Cyclosporine A/MP −11.5 (−92.5–69.5) 12 1 5.83% 0.0026
FK506 11.6 (−8.0–31.2) 80 6
Cyclosporine A 19.6 (13.7–25.4) 1,242 78
None 30.2 (27.2–33.1) 4,259 226
Cyclophosphamide 44.4 (−0.8–89.7) 36 1
Method used to induce SCI Impactor with spacer 11.6 (−11.3–34.5) 79 5 4.40% 0.0115
Aneurysm clip 18.7 (7.9–29.4) 356 20
Impactor 24.1 (20.4–27.8) 2,768 144
Unknown 27.8 (19.7–36) 665 35
Balloon compression 28.4 (15.8–41.1) 235 14
Compression weight 30.1 (20.3–39.9) 544 25
Blade 33.5 (26.4–40.6) 682 52
Scissors 42.5 (30–54.9) 278 16
Filament 79.2 (4.8–53.6) 20 1
Source of cells Cell line 41.1 (25.1–57.1) 131 7 4.34% 0.0034
Human 28.0 (21.6–34.3) 1,483 77
Mouse 18.0 (11.2–24.8) 877 56
Rat 29.2 (25.9–32.6) 3,136 172
Type of injury Contusion 23.8 (20.1–27.5) 2,847 149 3.44% 0.0073
Compression 25.8 (18.8–32.8) 1,135 59
Transection 30.5 (24.1–37)) 928 65
Hemisection 37.7 (29.1–46.2) 717 38
Blinded assessment of outcome Not blinded 30.3 (26.8–33.8) 2,975 165 2.21% 0.01
Blinded 23.6 (18.5–28.7) 2,653 147