Table 2. Study characteristics accounting for heterogeneity of motor score.
Motor Score | Effect size % (95% CI) | Number of Animals | Number of Comparisons | Adjusted R2 | p< | |
Pooled estimate | 27.2 (25.0–29.4) | 5,628 | 312 | |||
NBS | Motor tests | −8.1 (−37.7–21.4) | 49 | 3 | 12.24% | 0.00001 |
Staircase | −2.0 (−43.3–39.3) | 12 | 1 | |||
BMS | 24.5 (11.2–37.7) | 196 | 10 | |||
Multiple tests | 24.5 (17.8–31.2) | 1,053 | 56 | |||
BBB | 26.7 (23.9–29.4) | 4,042 | 228 | |||
Forelimb placing test | 47.9 (18.8–77.1) | 76 | 5 | |||
Tarlov | 73.1 (57.5–88.7) | 200 | 9 | |||
Location of injury | Cervical | 32.2 (12.2–52.3) | 156 | 13 | 10.64% | 0.00001 |
Lowerthoracic/lumbar | 48.1 (39.7–56.5) | 456 | 28 | |||
Midthoracic | 24.9 (22.3–27.5) | 5,016 | 271 | |||
Sex | Female | 22.9 (19.6–26.3) | 2,906 | 171 | 9.69% | 0.00001 |
Male | 27.4 (21.7–33.1) | 1,704 | 87 | |||
Unknown | 35.7 (27.9–43.5) | 676 | 37 | |||
Both | 48.7 (37.6–59.7) | 341 | 17 | |||
Immunosuppression | Cyclosporine A/MP | −11.5 (−92.5–69.5) | 12 | 1 | 5.83% | 0.0026 |
FK506 | 11.6 (−8.0–31.2) | 80 | 6 | |||
Cyclosporine A | 19.6 (13.7–25.4) | 1,242 | 78 | |||
None | 30.2 (27.2–33.1) | 4,259 | 226 | |||
Cyclophosphamide | 44.4 (−0.8–89.7) | 36 | 1 | |||
Method used to induce SCI | Impactor with spacer | 11.6 (−11.3–34.5) | 79 | 5 | 4.40% | 0.0115 |
Aneurysm clip | 18.7 (7.9–29.4) | 356 | 20 | |||
Impactor | 24.1 (20.4–27.8) | 2,768 | 144 | |||
Unknown | 27.8 (19.7–36) | 665 | 35 | |||
Balloon compression | 28.4 (15.8–41.1) | 235 | 14 | |||
Compression weight | 30.1 (20.3–39.9) | 544 | 25 | |||
Blade | 33.5 (26.4–40.6) | 682 | 52 | |||
Scissors | 42.5 (30–54.9) | 278 | 16 | |||
Filament | 79.2 (4.8–53.6) | 20 | 1 | |||
Source of cells | Cell line | 41.1 (25.1–57.1) | 131 | 7 | 4.34% | 0.0034 |
Human | 28.0 (21.6–34.3) | 1,483 | 77 | |||
Mouse | 18.0 (11.2–24.8) | 877 | 56 | |||
Rat | 29.2 (25.9–32.6) | 3,136 | 172 | |||
Type of injury | Contusion | 23.8 (20.1–27.5) | 2,847 | 149 | 3.44% | 0.0073 |
Compression | 25.8 (18.8–32.8) | 1,135 | 59 | |||
Transection | 30.5 (24.1–37)) | 928 | 65 | |||
Hemisection | 37.7 (29.1–46.2) | 717 | 38 | |||
Blinded assessment of outcome | Not blinded | 30.3 (26.8–33.8) | 2,975 | 165 | 2.21% | 0.01 |
Blinded | 23.6 (18.5–28.7) | 2,653 | 147 |