Table 4. Study characteristics accounting for heterogeneity of motor score—Randomised and blinded subset.
Motor Score | Effect Size % (95% CI) | Number of Animals | Number of Comparisons | Adjusted R2 | p< | |
Pooled estimate | 24.7(20.2–29.3) | 1,466 | 79 | |||
Method used to induce SCI | Aneurysm clip | −1.7 (−44.3–40.9) | 18 | 2 | 41.2% | 0.0000001 |
Balloon compression | 19.8 (0.1–39.4) | 79 | 6 | |||
Compression, weight | 21.9 (8–35.8) | 253 | 8 | |||
iridesctomy scissors | 57.6 (40.2–75) | 115 | 5 | |||
Impactor | 14.6 (7.9–21.3) | 680 | 34 | |||
Knife | 42 (29.2–54.8) | 169 | 11 | |||
Unknown | 23.1 (11.2–35) | 152 | 13 | |||
Type of injury | Compression | 20.2 (7.2–33.2) | 350 | 16 | 25.46% | 0.0007 |
Contusion | 14.7 (7.4–21.9) | 680 | 34 | |||
Hemisetion | 41.1 (27.354.9) | 240 | 12 | |||
Transection | 32.9 (21.1–44.8) | 196 | 17 | |||
Location of injury | LowerThoracic/Lumbar | 53.8 (37.9–69.7) | 78 | 7 | 23.68% | 0.000001 |
Midthoracic | 21.3 (16.4–26.2) | 1,388 | 72 | |||
NBS | BBB | 24.2 (19.1–29.3) | 1,165 | 66 | 22.51% | 0.0002 |
Multiple tests | 15.2 (2.1–28.4) | 241 | 11 | |||
Tarlov | 84.5 (54.7–114.3) | 60 | 2 | |||
Dose | 7.08 (3.52–1.06) for each additional million cells | 21.85% | 0.000001 | |||
Sex | Both | 53.8 (37.2–70.4) | 78 | 7 | 21.28% | 0.0015 |
Female | 21 (14.6–27.4) | 813 | 43 | |||
Male | 22.6 (12.3–32.8) | 553 | 28 | |||
Unknown | 3.2 (−39.2–45.6) | 22 | 1 | |||
Allocation concealment | Concealed | 37.1 (26.3–47.9) | 368 | 20 | 2.21% | 0.01 |
Not concealed | 19.4 (13.7–25.1) | 1,098 | 59 | |||
Cell culture medium | Antibiotic+Growith Factor | 23.2 (7.4–39.1) | 240 | 13 | 10.84% | 0.031 |
Growth Factor | 19.2 (12–26.3) | 663 | 36 | |||
Other | 26 (14.4–37.7) | 479 | 22 | |||
Unknown | 44.1 (27.7–60.6) | 84 | 8 | |||
Cell manipulations | Differentiation | 10.4 (−3.1–23.9) | 33 | 17 | 10.26% | 0.0224 |
Diff.+Transfection | 19.7 (−8.8–48.3) | 33 | 2 | |||
None | 27.3 (19.1–35.6) | 646 | 28 | |||
Transfection | 22.8 (8.9–36.7) | 272 | 18 | |||
Unknown | 36 (22.4–49.6) | 193 | 14 |