Skip to main content
. 2013 Nov 6;13(11):15187–15208. doi: 10.3390/s131115187

Table 1.

Comparative study of the properties of the three commonly used biorecepters.

Property Enzyme Antibody Aptamer
Acquisition In vitro process no animals are involved In vivo process -animals are involved In vitro process no animals are involved
All the toxins don't inhibit enzymatic activity or not substrate of enzyme Difficult to obtain antibodies against targets that are non-immunogenic or toxic Possible to obtain aptamers against targets that are non-immunogenic or toxic
Manipulation is not possible Physiological conditions obligatory Manipulation of selection hardly or not possible Physiological conditions obligatory Manipulate selection to obtain binding and kinetic properties desirable for specific assays Non-physiological conditions acceptable
Difficult to expose different epitopes of the same target for selection Identification laborious the immunogen must be the major fraction in the immunization reagent Expose different epitopes of the same target for selection Identification easy and rapid process performed on automated platform the target used for selection can be a small portion in the target preparation

Stability Increased by modifications Cannot be increased by modification Increased by modifications
Loss activity over time Narrow stability in terms of pH, ionic strength and temperature Relatively stable over time Narrow stability in terms of pH, ionic strength and temperature Relatively stable over time Stability over a wide range of pH, ionic strength and temperature
Unstable at room temperature Unstable at room temperature Long room temperature shelf lives

Specificity and selectivity Less selective and specific Can be engineered Binding constants for target species comparable with aptamers Binding constants for target species comparable with antibodies

Modifications Can be engineered Biological and hardly engineered Chemically easy to engineer Side specific attachment
Efficient and exact modification
  • -

    of reporter molecule

  • -

    of spacers

  • -

    of functional groups

Homogeneous product

Denaturation Enzyme accelerates the reaction and does not consume Mild conditions needed to prevent irreversible denaturation Regeneration after denaturation possible
Sometimes difficult to separate from antibody-target-complex Easy to separate from aptamer-target-complex

Sensors Immobilization at defined densities and locations difficult Immobilization at defined densities and locations sometimes difficult Immobilization at defined densities at precise locations on solid surfaces (microarrays)
Immobilization can denature enzyme Molecular recognition functionalities hardly possible Conformational changes on binding providing molecular-recognition functionalities Irreversible
Irreversible cross-linking usually not possible cross-linking with target protein possible-second legand for detection not needed