Table 1. Preclinical assessment of therapeutic strategies in DM1 mouse models.
Mouse modela | Therapeutic strategiesb | Quantifiable phenotypes in target tissues | Limitations | Refs | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Skeletal muscle | Heart | CNS | Others | ||||
HSALR | Elimination of toxic RNA, disruption of RNA–MBNL protein interactions, MBNL upregulation, restoration of missplicing | Myotonia, myopathy, foci accumulation, MBNL1 sequestration, missplicing events | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not applicable | No muscle weakness, normal CELF1 levels | [43] |
EpA960 | Elimination of toxic RNA, disruption of RNA–MBNL protein interactions, MBNL upregulation, CELF1 downregulation, PKC inactivation | Myotonia, motor function, muscle wasting, myopathy, foci accumulation, MBNL1 sequestration, missplicing events | Cardiac conduction defects, cardiomyopathy, foci accumulation, MBNL1 sequestration, missplicing events | Not reported | Not reported | Leakage of transgene expression in skeletal muscle, high mortality due to cardiac complications | [9,53,54] |
DM300 and/or DMSXL | Elimination of toxic RNA, disruption of RNA–MBNL protein interactions, MBNL upregulation, restoration of missplicing, modification of triplet repeat dynamics | Myotonia, myopathy, foci accumulation, muscle strength, missplicing events | Foci accumulation, missplicing events | Foci accumulation, missplicing events, tauopathy | Foci accumulation, missplicing events | Mild splicing abnormalities, interindividual variability, time-consuming breeding strategies | [47,49,51, 98,99] |
DMPK-GFP-(CTG)5 | Elimination of toxic RNA, NKX2-5 downregulation | Myotonia, myopathy, missplicing events. | Cardiac conduction defects | Not reported | Not reported | No muscle weakness, no RNA foci, short repeat sequence, high mortality | [52] |
Mbnl1Δ3/Δ3 | MBNL upregulation or replacement | Myotonia, myopathy, missplicing events | Cardiomyopathy | Motivation and apathy deficits | Not reported | No muscle weakness, normal CELF1 levels | [59,61] |
TRECUGBP1 | CELF1 downregulation, restoration of missplicing | Motor function, myopathy, muscle weight, missplicing events | Cardiac conduction defects, cardiomyopathy | Not reported | Not reported | High mortality | [11,12] |
Different mouse lines have different advantages and limitations in assessing the benefits and efficacy of new therapeutic schemes in specific tissues and organ systems.
Possible therapeutic approaches are presented for mouse models that replicate key events in the biochemical cascade of RNA toxicity and develop relevant DM1 phenotypes.