Table 1.
List of key references recommending the use of cosmetic agents in combination with chemotherapy
Author | Study design | Title | Comments | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Lacouture9 | Review | Mechanisms of cutaneous toxicity | |||
Segaert S et al.7 | Review article | Clinical signs, pathophysiology and management skin toxicity | Adequate sun protection | ||
Avoid skin drying cosmetic products | |||||
An emollient on hands and limbs to prevent fissures | |||||
Segaert S et al.6 | Review article | Skin toxicities of targeted therapy | Maximize skin hydration | ||
Sun protection | |||||
Rash: Avoid retinoids | |||||
Xerosis: oil-in-water creams, 5-10% urea | |||||
Paronychia: Topical antiseptic | |||||
Robert C et al.5 | Review article | Cutaneous side-effects of kinase inhibitors and blocking antibodies | Camouflage cosmetics for folliculitis | ||
Xerosis: prescribe 5–10% urea | |||||
Ouwerkerk, J et al.30 | Review article | Anti EGFR for metastatic colorectal cancer | Sunscreen >15+ | ||
Avoid cleaning detergents | |||||
Mild body cleansers | |||||
Moisturizers | |||||
Avoid alcohol-based products | |||||
Cosmetics to conceal rash | |||||
Gentle non-alcohol-based cleansers | |||||
Perez-Soler et al.14 | Guideline | HER1/EGFRI assoc rash: future directions for mgt and outcomes from the HER1/EGFRI rash management forum | Cover rash with make-up | ||
Use a skin-friendly make-up remover | |||||
Use emollients to prevent skin dryness | |||||
Use a good sunscreen | |||||
Avoid over-the-counter acne medication | |||||
Burtness et al.1 | Guideline | Task force report. Management of dermatological and other toxicities associated with EGFRI in patients with cancer. | Initiate treatment early | ||
Avoid using antiacne medication | |||||
Thick emollients | |||||
Mild soap | |||||
Bernier et al.36 | Guideline | Consensus guidelines for the mgt of radiation dermatitis and acne-like rash in patients receiving radiotherapy+ EGFRI for the treatment of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma | Use gentle cleansers | ||
Topical cosmetics for symptomatic relief | |||||
Avoid sun exposure (mineral sunblocks or clothing) | |||||
Avoid perfumes and alcohol-based lotions. | |||||
Lynch TJ et al.6 | Guideline | EGFRI dermatologic toxicity overview of outcomes. | Expert opinion | ||
Initiation of treatment, moisturize dry areas twice daily | |||||
Thick alcohol-free emollient | |||||
Broad-spectrum sunscreen 15+ or higher | |||||
Add Medical treatment if severity increases. | |||||
Infections | |||||
Grenader T et al23 | Case report | Staph aureus on culture following erlotinib treatment |
Author | Study Design | Population | Intervention | Sample size | Outcome measurement | Results | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Fluhr 21 | 3-week, controlled, monocentric, study | Experiencing dry, sensitive skin during chemotherapy | Application of acidic pH 5.5 washing emulsion and body lotion | 30 | Skin-surface pH | Improved skin physiology | |||||||
TEWL | Sig increase in stratum corneum hydration P < 0.001 | ||||||||||||
Corneometer | Reduced TEWL P > 0.007 | ||||||||||||
Sebumeter | Significant reduction of skin symptoms P < 0.001 | ||||||||||||
Clinical evaluation | |||||||||||||
Roé E et al29 | Prospective, uncontrolled study of toxicity | Cetuximab or erlotinib | Severity graded | 30 | Application of an emollient for treatment of xerosis | Good control of symptoms. | No description of which cosmetic products used when. | ||||||
Antiseptic soaps | |||||||||||||
Pre-emptive skin-care management reduces incidence and severity of skin rash | |||||||||||||
Wohlrab34 | Monocentre POC | Breast cancer chemotherapy | Application of an emollient | 13 | DLQI – quality-of-life questionnaire | Maintains quality of life and reduces frequency of adverse events | Poster | ||||||
Ocvirk J et al 22 | Prospective, monocentre, uncontrolled study | cetuximab Review of local practice for management of skin toxicity | Application of an emollient after the first documented cutaneous toxicity | 31 | Skin toxicity Classification using NCI CTCAE v3.0 | 29.03% grade 1 – advised emollients | Recommend prompt application of topical emollients. Add topical of systemic medication for increasing severity. | ||||||
Xerosis | Grade 1 were treated with emollients | 51.61% grade 2 – advised emollients + topical antibiotic | |||||||||||
fissures | Grade 2 emollients+ antibiotics | 19.36% grade 3 – interruption of treatment then emollients + topical antibiotics | |||||||||||
Grade 3 emollients+ systemic antibiotics | Xerosis – advised emollients 2–5% urea | ||||||||||||
Fissures – creams + dexpanthenol | |||||||||||||
Use of beauty care and cosmetics improves quality of life and management of side-effects | |||||||||||||
Boone SL et al13 | Qualitative Survey | Oncology providers | 51 item, open-ended questionnaire pertaining to incidence of rash among patients on EGFRI, treatment practices, patient perceptions, outcome treating rash | 110 | 71–90% of patients experience rash. | ||||||||
8% of providers surveyed obtained a dermatology consult. | |||||||||||||
Grade 3 and 4 rash interfered with EGFRI therapy (3%). | |||||||||||||
Taggart L et al39 | Pilot study | Cancer patients | Participation at a look-good–feel-better workshop | 20 | Self-image NSC | Improved self-image (P < 0.005) | |||||||
Anxiety STAI | Reduced anxiety (P < 0.01) | ||||||||||||
Haley et al18 | Monocentre, uncontrolled study | Cancer patients receiving either cytotoxic chemotherapy, targeted, or hormonal and/or radiotherapy | Applied three test products after first toxicity visit skin and face moisturizer and face wash | 99 | Q of L: Skindex questionnaire | Significant decrease (P = 0.0003) from baseline in mean overall skindex score | |||||||
Merial-Kieny C et al52 | Multicentre qualitative survey | Visible cutaneous side-effects following chemotherapy | Participated in a make-up training seminar | 90 | Self-completed questionnaire on tolerance, quality of life and the make-up techniques | 95,4% very or satisfied with tolerance | |||||||
Applied a hypoallergenic make-up | 81,2% improved their quality of life. | ||||||||||||
Amiel P et al40 | Multicentre, qualitative survey | Cancer patients | Survey of patient experience receiving various beauty-care services | 60 | Observation and semistructured interviews | 18/40 appreciated information on treating skin problems | |||||||
23/40 appreciated information on make-up techniques | |||||||||||||
Titeca G et al41 | Prospective, randomized, controlled multicentre study | Breast cancer Antitumor chemotherapy | 2H cosmetic care interview | 27 | VQ dermatological questionnaire | less discouraged (P = 0.032) | |||||||
more self-confident (P = 0.032) | |||||||||||||
Williams S et al46 | Outpatient chemotherapy clinics | First chemotherapy Breast cancer patients | Informational audiotapes for self care | 70 | STAI | Treatment group increased use of management techniques | |||||||
Symptoms decreased |
TEWL, Trans Epidermal Water Loss; NCI-CTC, National Cancer Institute cutaneous toxicity Criteria.