Table 3.
Phenomenologists Following Jaspers
| Authors | Phenomenological Hypothesis Concerning Delusions and Schizophrenia |
|---|---|
| Matussek58,59 | Loosening of the “natural” connectedness between objects (Auflockerung des naturlichen Wahrnehmungszusammenhang) results in the “releasing” of expressive physiognomic qualities |
| Conrad53 | Reduced energy capacity, release of the Gestalt physiognomic qualities (protopathic functional change of the Vorgestalt) (Hughlings Jackson, H. Head, von Weizsaecker) |
| Kisker60 | Reorganization of field of consciousness |
| Ey61 | Disruption of field of consciousness based on Hughlings Jackson’s hierarchical model of brain function |
| Binswanger51,52 | Loosening of mnemic schema, failure of self-transcendence, similar to dreaming, loss of distance, temporal shrinking to the present |
| Blankenburg62–64 | Loss of common sense, becoming independent of the delusional theme, inability to exchange perspectives or shift reference frames |
| Blankenburg63,64 | Only self-critical phenomenological method and awareness of limits will prevent a return to subjectivism in psychiatry |
Note: Phenomenologists tempered by Jaspers’ sobering critique take more modest position regarding phenomenologically generated hypotheses concerning individual symptoms. Reprinted from Mishara and Schwartz7 Copyright (2013), with permission from S. Karger AG, Basel.