Skip to main content
. 2013 May 31;9(7):1500–1511. doi: 10.4161/hv.24704

Table 1. Study characteristics of included studies.

Source Objective Type Based on Currency Analytic horizon Dis-counting Influenza outcome Impact Uncertainty analysis Funding source
Aballéa et al.40 Economic evaluation of lowering the age threshold in various countries for influenza vaccination from currently 60 or 65 y to all people aged 50 y and older CUA Model Brazilian real Not reported Life expectancy in unadjusted life years and quality-adjusted life years (3% per annum) ILI; minor complications; hospitalization for pneumonia and influenza, for other respiratory complications, and other complications; and deaths QALY gained One-way sensitivity/ threshold analysis and PSA IVS International Task Force
Chicaiza-Becerra et al.41 Cost-effectiveness evaluation of implementing a vaccination program for health workers in contact with hospitalized oncological patients CEA Model Colombian peso Not reported Not applicable Days hospitalized for influenza-related complications Cost-effectiveness ratio (additional days of hospitalization prevented) One-way sensitivity analysis for different transmission probabilities Not specifically mentioned
Dayan et al.24 To compare from the societal perspective the costs and benefits of a general influenza vaccination program in high-risk children with no vaccination CEA Model US dollars 12 mo Not applicable Influenza outcomes including outpatient visits, otitis media and hospitalization influenza episodes averted One-way sensitivity/ threshold analysis and PSA Not specifically mentioned
Gutiérrez et al.43 Estimation of costs and health outcomes achievable by vaccination of people aged 65 y and older CEA Model Mexican peso 5 mo Costs per life year saved by different discount rates (3% assumed as bases, estimates provided for 0%, 5%, 10%) Pneumonia-and influenza-associated deaths and cases Life years saved, costs per life year saved PSA National public health institute
Porras-Ramirez et al.42 Evaluating the economic value of influenza vaccination of infants aged below 2 y and elderly aged 65 y and above CEA Model US dollars 1 y 3% discounting Among below 2 y old: annual number of cases of ARI, medical visits, hospitalizations and deaths from ARI
Among 65 y and above: annual number of deaths and hospitalizations due to cardiocirculatory diseases.
ARI-related hospitalization prevented, direct costs saved annually Univariate sensitivity analysis Ministry for social protection
Gao et al.46 To assess cost benefit of vaccinating employers insured under a social-health program; results extrapolated to the whole population of the city CBA RCT Chinese yuan 5 y Not reported Respiratory system diseases and other chronic diseases such as cardiovascular diseases Respiratory system disease and cardio-vascular diseases related hospitalization costs averted Sensitivity analysis for vaccination coverage Not specifically mentioned
Liu et al.47 To compare vaccinated with non-vaccinated elderly and estimate effectiveness. CBA RCT Chinese yuan 6 mo Not reported. ILI incidence and related chronic diseases such as common cold, other respiratory tract or chronic disease such as diabetes Medical consultations and number of hospital day-related costs averted None performed Not specifically mentioned
Praditsuwan et al.44 To determine cost effectiveness of influenza vaccination in the Thai elderly living in an urban community compared with placebo CEA RCT Thai baht Not reported Not reported ILI, upper respiratory infection, and serologically confirmed influenza. Unclear None performed National Research Council of Thailand
Wongsurakiat et al.45 To determine cost- effectiveness and cost-benefit of influenza vaccination in COPD patients compared with placebo CEA RCT Thai baht 16–18 mo Not applicable Influenza-like outcomes including episodes of acute respiratory illness Acute respiratory infection episodes averted None performed National Research Council of Thailand

CBA, cost-benefit analysis; CUA, cost-utility analysis; CEA, cost-effectiveness analysis; QALY, quality adjusted life years; PSA, probabilistic sensitivity analysis; ILI, influenza-like illness.