Skip to main content
. 2014 Jan 13;9(1):e84847. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0084847

Table 3. Examples of each magnitude of non-target impact on plants from weed classical biological control agents.

Target species Non-target species Cause & predictability Potential threat References
Minimal Ulex europaeus L. Genista monspessulana (L.) L.A.S. Johnson Deliberate release of two populations of Cydia succedana (Denis and Schiffermüller), one showed limited development on weeds including this one; Predictable None, majority of examples [24], [61]
Minor Hypericum perforatum L. Hypericum concinnum Benth Deliberate release of Chrysolina quadrigemina in California causing damage and varying impact on H. concinnum, it is still common; Predictable None, some examples [80]
Moderate Carduus nutans L. Cirsium altissimum L. Spreng Deliberate release of Trichosirocalus horridus causing damage on non-target native thistles; Predictable Too early to tell; impact is uncertain (moderate impact may be too high); rare. [81], [82]
Major Carduus nutans L. Cirsium canescens, Nutt.& Carduus Deliberate release of Rhinocyllus conicus in the U.S. mainland following host range testing proving its safety for crops. Evidence of local population decline of Cirsium canescens; Predictable High likelihood of some attacks on ∼28 species of native thistles; otherwise rare. [19], [83]
Massive Opuntia lindheimeri, Engelm., O. stricta, (Haw.) Haw., O. triacantha (Willdenow) Sweet Opuntia spinosissima P.Mill. Accidental release of Cactoblactis cactorum in the U.S. mainland following introduction against cacti in the Caribbean; severe feeding impact (threat of extinction without intervention?); Predictable High likelihood of attacks on ∼87 native cacti species (too early to tell for most); rare. [27], [45], [46], [70]