1a. Two criminals robbed a jewelry store on the same night. One stole an expensive diamond and the other stole a ring. |
The policeman discovered the criminal with the expensive diamond. (NP-attachment) |
1b. A criminal had been hiding out in an apartment for months. A policeman watched the apartment with a hidden microphone and a video camera. |
The policeman discovered the criminal with the hidden microphone. (VP-attachment) |
2a. A knight saw two queens were in trouble. One queen had a big heart and was very kind. The other queen was cruel. |
The knight rescued the queen with the big heart. (NP-attachment) |
2b. A knight saw his queen was in trouble. In his hands he carried a sword and a bow that he could use to free her. |
The knight rescued the queen with the sword. (VP-attachment) |
3a. A deer found two trails that crossed in the woods. One trail was older but the other was covered in fresh footprints. |
The deer smelled the trail with the footprints. (NP-attachment) |
3b. A deer came across an animal’s trail in the woods. The deer sensed danger. |
The deer smelled the trail with careful attention. (VP-attachment) |
4a. The fortuneteller was afraid to look into the future. Either it would be a lovely future or a future with many new problems. |
The fortuneteller saw the future with its new problems. (NP-attachment) |
4b. The fortuneteller had cards and a crystal ball at her disposal. |
The fortuneteller saw the future with the cards. (VP-attachment) |
5a. A professor could not remember who had the first appointment of the semester. Was he tutoring the freshman with the black bag or the freshman with the red backpack? |
The professor taught the freshman with the red backpack. (NP-attachment) |
5b. The professor met with a freshman from his course, who had brought a book and a calculator to the professor’s office hours. The freshman clearly needed a lot of help. |
The professor taught the freshman with the help of the book. (VP-attachment) |
6a. The manager of a large company had two secretaries: one with two children who worked very diligently and one without children who always went home at 4:00. |
The manager thanked the secretary with two children. (NP-attachment) |
6b. The manager of a large company had a secretary who had worked quite a bit of overtime in the last few months. He wanted to thank her. |
The manager thanked the secretary with a bouquet of flowers. (VP-attachment) |
7a. Nina absolutely wanted to see a soccer game. She had two options: either a really big game with a lot of fans or a smaller game in her home town. |
Nina saw the game with a lot of spectators. (NP-attachment) |
7b. Nina absolutely wanted to see the soccer game. But there were only two tickets left. So she could either go with her mother or with her brother. |
Nina saw the game with her brother. (VP-attachment) |
8a. During a hold-up, a thief wanted money from two men. One man gave the thief twenty dollars. The other man had no money. |
The thief hit the man with no money. (NP-attachment) |
8b. A man surprised a thief. The thief knew he could hit the man with a chair or a computer. |
The thief hit the man with a chair. (VP-attachment) |
9a. A gangster saw two of his rivals in a park at night. One wore a yellow hat. The other wore a black sweater. |
The gangster followed his rival with the black sweater. (NP-attachment) |
9b. A gangster saw his rival in a park at night. The gangster had a motorcycle and a bicycle. |
The gangster followed his rival with the motorcycle. (VP-attachment) |
10a. Two kittens walked into Stephan’s garden. One kitten had a brownish tail and the other had a white tail. Stephan really didn’t like cats. |
Stephan kicked the kitten with the brownish tail. (NP-attachment) |
10b. A kitten walked into Stephan’s garden. To scare it away, Stephan could kick it or spray it with water. |
Stephan kicked the kitten with his foot. (VP-attachment) |
11a. The cook needed to hold one kind of cheese over the stove. The cook had blue cheese and a cheese with a rind. |
The cook held the cheese with the rind. (NP-attachment) |
11b. The cook needed to hold cheese over the stove so that he could melt it into the pan. He could use a fork or a spoon. |
The cook held the cheese with the fork. (VP-attachment) |
12a. The queen bought the king two crowns as presents. One crown had large jewels on it. The other was silver. The king searched for his presents. |
The king saw the crown with the large jewels. (NP-attachment) |
12b. A crown was in a museum in England. The king had to decide if he should go to the exhibit himself or send his servant to see it. |
The king saw the crown with his very own eyes. (VP-attachment) |
13a. Up until now the actor had only landed funny roles. This time he decided to play a more serious role. He had two options: he could either play the role of a sick boy or that of a boy from the slums. |
The actor portrayed the boy with a blood disease. (NP-attachment) |
13b. Up until now the actor had only landed funny roles. This time he decided to play a more serious role. He wanted to play it as well as he could. |
The actor portrayed the boy with enthusiasm. (VP-attachment) |
14a. A doctor went into the waiting room and saw two men. One had broken his leg and the other had a fever. |
The doctor examined the man with the fever. (NP-attachment) |
14b. A man has been sick since yesterday and had problems with his heart and his breathing. The doctor wanted to examine everything. |
The doctor examined the man with the stethoscope. (VP-attachment) |