Skip to main content
. 2014 Jan 15;14:37. doi: 10.1186/1471-2458-14-37

Table 1.

Quality assessment criteria

  Application of the criteria to specific study designs Definition of each criterion
Study objective
All
A specific objective has been clearly formulated.
Study population
All
The response rate is at least 80%.
Prospective
The response rate is at least 80% after at least one year or the non-responders are not selective.
Case–control
Cases and controls originate from the same population and there is a clear definition of cases and controls.
Exposure
All
The original ERI questionnaire was used, including the ascertainment of over-commitment.
All
Data on physical work-related stress was collected and taken into account in the analysis.
Outcome
Case–control
Prospective enrolment was used (identification of new cases and selection of controls occurs at the same time).
Prospective
Follow-up completed at least one year later.
Analysis All Risk predictors including confidence intervals or p-values were calculated and confounding was controlled for.