Table 1.
Category | Sub-category | Description/Notes | Variables |
---|---|---|---|
Which children are protected under the law | Age of child a | The age range at which a child passenger is required to use a child restraint device/rear seat/seat belt | Minimum and maximum ages for infant seat, toddler seat, booster seat, and non-specified general child restraint (8 variables) |
Weight of child a | The weight range at which a child passenger is required to use a child restraint device/rear seat/seat belt | Minimum and maximum weights for infant seat, toddler seat, booster seat, and non-specified general child restraint (8 variables) | |
Height of child a | The height range at which a child passenger is required to use a child restraint device/rear seat/seat belt | Minimum and maximum heights for infant seat, toddler seat, booster seat, and non-specified general child restraint (8 variables) | |
Miscellaneous | Whether the law requires a child passenger to be restrained until the age AND height/weight requirements are met (as opposed to OR) | Yes/No binary variable for infant seat, toddler seat, booster seat, and non-specified general child restraint (4 variables) | |
What action should be taken in order to comply with the law | Type of restraint device required | Whether the law specifies a device type (such as a booster seat) depending on the child’s age, weight and/or height | Yes/No binary variable for existence of explicit infant, toddler and booster seat laws, as well as implicit laws for each (6 variables) |
Quality of restraint device | Whether the law requires the operator to use only those devices that meet federal or state safety standards | Yes/no binary variable for infant seat, toddler seat, booster seat and general child restraint (4 variables) | |
Method of installing and using a restraint device | Whether the law requires the operator to use devices in a manner consistent with physicians’ and or scientists’ recommendations (e.g. placing an infant seat in a rear-facing position) | Yes/no binary variable for infant seat (rear-facing), toddler seat (forward-facing) and booster seat (strapped with seatbelt) (3 variables) | |
Seat belt substitution | Whether the law allows the operator to substitute a child restraint device with a seatbelt (usually when the child passenger at issue is above a certain age, weight and/or height limit). | min. age, max. age, min. weight, max. weight, min. height, max. height, whether the substitution is allowed after the age AND weight/height requirements are met (7 variables) | |
How the law is enforced | Primary enforcement vs. secondary enforcement | Whether law enforcement officers can stop the vehicles solely based on noncompliance with child passenger safety laws or not | Yes/no binary variable for child restraint law (1 variable) |
What the penalties are for non-compliance | Type of penalty | Whether there is a fine, license points, insurance points, or mandatory education requirement | min. fine, max. fine, min. license points, max. license points, min. insurance points, max. insurance points, existence of mandatory education for the violation (7 variables) |
Waiver | Whether there is a first-time waiver, a fee waiver for indigent populations, or a waiver for subsequent proof of restraint device purchase or education program attendance | existence of each waiver (3 variables) | |
Who should comply with the law and who is exempted from doing so | Exemptions | See Table | See Table 3 (23 variables) |
Some states combined two or more of the three categories in defining its target child group (e.g. “a child who is less than X years old and weighs less than Y is required to use a restraint device”) or used either/or terms (e.g. “a child under the age of X or the height of Y is required to use a restraint device”).